What Ethical Guidelines Are and Why They Exist
- Ethical guidelines are rules researchers follow to protect the rights and wellbeing of the people who take part.
- They exist because a study can teach us something useful and still wrong the people in it, so the two have to be balanced.
- There are seven you need to know: informed consent, avoiding deception, debriefing, the right to withdraw, minimising harm, confidentiality and privacy.
- Each guideline protects a different right, so learn what each one is and the one thing that breaks it.
- In the exam you name the guideline and point to exactly what in the study puts it at risk.
Consent, Deception and Debriefing
Informed consent
Informed consent
Agreeing to take part in a study after being told what it involves, including any risks, so the decision to join is a genuine, free choice.
- Consent must be valid: people agree to take part knowing what the study involves and any risks, and their agreement is freely given.
- For anyone under 16, a parent or guardian gives consent on their behalf.
- Without it, a person cannot make a genuine choice about joining, so the study wrongs them from the start.
Avoiding deception
Deception
Deliberately misleading participants about the aim or nature of a study, or withholding information they would need to give real consent.
- Deception means deliberately giving participants wrong or incomplete information about the study.
- It blocks informed consent, because you cannot truly agree to something you were never told about.
- Mild deception is sometimes accepted when a study could not work any other way, but it has to be justified and put right afterwards.
Debriefing
Debriefing
A full explanation given to participants after a study, telling them its true aim, revealing any deception and offering support, so they leave fully informed.
- A debrief happens after the data are collected, when you tell participants the study's true aim.
- It is how you reduce the impact of any deception, so people leave knowing what they really took part in.
- It is also the moment to check nobody is distressed and to remind them they can still withdraw their data.
Withdrawal, Harm, Confidentiality and Privacy
Right to withdraw
Right to withdraw
The participant's right to stop taking part at any point, and to have their data removed, without giving a reason or facing any penalty.
- Participants must know they can stop and leave at any point, without giving a reason.
- They can also ask for their data to be removed after the study has finished.
Minimising harm, including maximising benefit
Protection from harm
Making sure participants are not put at risk of physical or psychological harm, and are left in no worse a state than when they arrived.
- Participants should face no greater physical or psychological risk than they would in everyday life.
- That covers stress, embarrassment and fear, and means they leave in no worse a state than when they arrived.
- Maximising benefit is the other half: the study should aim to produce something worthwhile, such as useful knowledge, so any small risk is justified.
Confidentiality
Confidentiality
Keeping participants' personal data and identity private, so their results cannot be traced back to them.
- Confidentiality means keeping personal data and identity private, so results cannot be traced back to a named person.
- Using code numbers or false names instead of real ones is how you protect it.
Privacy
Privacy
Respecting people's personal space and not intruding on them where they expect to be unobserved, and not making participants reveal personal details they would rather keep private.
- Privacy is about the person, not just their data: you do not intrude on people where they expect to be unobserved.
- You also should not press participants into revealing personal details the study does not need.
- So confidentiality guards the data, while privacy guards the person and their personal space.
- A psychologist secretly films shoppers in a supermarket to record helping behaviour.
- The shoppers never agreed to take part, so there is no informed consent.
- They are filmed where they expect not to be studied, which invades their privacy.
- If the footage shows recognisable faces next to names, confidentiality is broken too.
Naming the Right Guideline in the Exam
- Ask whether the people knew what they were agreeing to, which tests consent and deception.
- Ask whether they were distressed, unable to leave, watched in private, or identifiable, which tests harm, withdrawal, privacy and confidentiality.
- Name each guideline and point to the exact detail in the study that puts it at risk.
- Name the seven ethical guidelines.
- What makes consent valid?
- When does a debrief happen, and what is it for?
- What is the difference between confidentiality and privacy?
- What does minimising harm, including maximising benefit, mean?