Dr Bell is investigating whether distracting sounds affect proofreading accuracy. In a pilot study, adult volunteers proofread safety instructions for 30 minutes while unpredictable harsh sounds were played. The volunteers had been fully informed and could stop at any time.
Dr Bell asked the volunteers to rate their stress before and after the task. After the task, he also asked them to report the highest stress they had experienced during an ordinary working day in the previous week.
| Measurement | Mean stress rating, from 0 (no stress) to 10 (extreme stress) |
|---|---|
| Before the task | 2.2 |
| After the task | 8.1 |
| Highest during an ordinary working day | 4.7 |
Dr Bell plans to use the same procedure in the main study. He argues that the study will produce useful knowledge that could improve the design of safety instructions.
Using the pilot results, explain whether Dr Bell's proposed main study meets the guidelines on minimising harm and maximising benefit. Explain one change Dr Bell should make to the procedure.
147 exam-style questions on CIE IGCSE Psychology 7.7.2 Application of ethical guidelines. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.