Two observers independently watch the same 20 video clips of adults completing a group route-planning task. For each clip, they decide whether one participant shows ‘leadership’. The observers often disagree because each uses their own idea of what leadership looks like.
The researcher tests two possible changes.
| Change | Number of clips on which the observers agree |
|---|---|
| 1: Both observers use a checklist defining leadership as giving an instruction, allocating a task or summarising the group’s decision | 18 out of 20 |
| 2: Both observers first watch five practice clips together and discuss them, without a written definition of leadership | 14 out of 20 |
Suggest which change the researcher should adopt. Use both results to explain why this change better addresses the disagreement, and state what would be expected if the observation were repeated using this change.
52 exam-style questions on CIE IGCSE Psychology 7.6.4 Application of reliability. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.