A researcher aims to measure how optimistic adults' written accounts of retirement are. The researcher rates each account from 1 (not optimistic) to 10 (very optimistic). The researcher has previously said that gardening is their favourite leisure activity.
To check the ratings, a colleague writes 12 pairs of accounts. The two accounts in each pair use the same positive and negative wording, but one mentions gardening and the other mentions a different leisure activity. The researcher rates all 24 accounts without being told that they are paired.
| Leisure activity mentioned | Mean rating |
|---|---|
| Gardening | 8.1 |
| A different leisure activity | 5.2 |
Explain what the results suggest about whether the ratings are subjective and how this may affect the validity of the study.
12 exam-style questions on CIE IGCSE Psychology 7.6.1 Validity. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.