A researcher investigates whether seeing a short thank-you message affects helpfulness during a ten-minute paired classroom clear-up task. Participants either see the message before the task or do not see it. The researcher measures helpfulness by counting how many times each participant smiles. To check this measure, an observer also records how many times each participant hands their partner an item that the partner has requested.
The mean results are shown below.
| Condition | Mean number of smiles | Mean number of requested items handed to the partner |
|---|---|---|
| Thank-you message | 8.6 | 3.1 |
| No message | 5.2 | 5.7 |
Using the results, explain why the number of smiles is not a suitable measure of helpfulness.
124 exam-style questions on CIE IGCSE Psychology 7.1 Experimental method, covering 7.1.1 Features of an experiment, 7.1.2 Application of experiments, 7.1.3 Independent variable, 7.1.4 Dependent variable, 7.1.5 Application of independent and dependent variables, 7.1.6 Operationalisation of variables, 7.1.7 Application of operationalisation, 7.1.8 Experimental design, 7.1.9 Application of experimental designs, 7.1.10 Repeated measures design, 7.1.11 Application of repeated measures designs, 7.1.12 Independent measures design, 7.1.13 Application of independent measures designs, 7.1.14 Experimental conditions, 7.1.15 Application of experimental conditions, 7.1.16 Experimental groups, 7.1.17 Control groups, 7.1.18 Application of experimental and control groups, 7.1.19 Extraneous variable, 7.1.20 Control, and 7.1.21 Application of extraneous variables and controls. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.