The Argument Against Cultural Influence
- Not all the evidence backs a strong cultural account of perception.
- Some illusions work on almost everyone, whatever culture they come from.
- That points to processing that is built in rather than learned, so there are universal aspects of perception.
- Shared illusion effects across the world suggest a common, innate basis for perception.
- Depth perception also appears very early in life, before culture could have taught it.
Consistency Across Cultures
- Many basic illusions are seen the same way by people across very different cultures.
- Some basic depth cues are read similarly whether you grew up in a city or the countryside.
- If culture decided everything, you would not expect this shared reaction.
- So at least part of perception looks hard-wired from birth.
- Very young babies show early depth perception on the visual cliff, long before culture could teach it.
- This hints that reading some depth cues is built in, not learned from the surrounding culture.
Building the Argument
- State that some illusions and basic depth cues are experienced consistently across very different cultures.
- Conclude that innate, universal processing must also play a part, so it is nature and nurture together.
- Most psychologists now accept that both shape perception; the live question is how much each contributes, not whether one wins outright.
- What does consistency across cultures suggest about perception?
- What does early depth perception on the visual cliff suggest about culture's role?
- Give one aspect of perception that looks innate rather than learned.
- What do most psychologists now conclude about nature and nurture in perception?