Culture, Attention and Illusions
- People from different cultures do not all experience the same visual illusion to the same degree.
- A key reason is differences in attention: cultures differ in how much they attend to the whole scene and its background rather than the single central object.
- Because many illusions depend on the surrounding context, how you spread your attention changes how strongly the illusion works.
- If perception were purely built-in, everyone would experience an illusion identically.
- Because attention differs with cultural experience, at least part of perception must be learned.
Differences in Attention
- Some cultural groups tend to attend broadly, taking in the whole scene and the context around an object.
- Others tend to focus more narrowly on the central, focal object and pay less heed to its surroundings.
- In an illusion like the Ebbinghaus, the surrounding circles are the context, so the more you attend to them, the more they distort your judgement of the central circle.
- Someone who attends strongly to the whole display is pulled in by the ring of surrounding circles and misjudges the central one.
- Someone who focuses on the central circle alone is far less fooled, because the context has less grip on their attention.
What This Tells You About Perception
- Illusion susceptibility is not fixed for the whole human race; it varies with cultural experience.
- Groups with less experience of 2D pictures, or who attend differently to context, are fooled less by some illusions.
- This supports the role of learning, and fits Gregory's view that experience builds perception.
- This feeds straight into the nature-nurture debate about perception.
- The next two guides give the argument for the cultural account, using Bremner et al., and the argument against it.
Answering a Question on Culture and Illusions
- State that culture affects how strongly illusions work, then explain the reason as differences in attention.
- The mark students miss is the mechanism, so link attention to context directly to how much the illusion fools someone, rather than just saying cultures differ.
- How can differences in attention change how strongly an illusion works?
- Why does attending more to the surrounding context increase the Ebbinghaus illusion?
- What does cultural variation in illusions suggest about perception?
- Which side of the nature-nurture debate does this support?