The Argument Against Gibson's Theory
- Gibson says perception comes straight from the input, with no help from prior knowledge.
- The main objection is that this ignores two powerful influences on what you perceive: expectation and culture.
- Both change how people perceive the very same input, which a purely direct theory cannot explain.
- If the input alone were enough, everyone would perceive an identical scene in exactly the same way.
- In fact expectation and culture shift what people see, so the input cannot be the whole story.
Expectation
- A great deal of everyday perception leans on expectation and past experience.
- You can read a friend's rushed, scrawled note only because you expect certain words, filling gaps the marks on the page never supply.
- In the Müller-Lyer illusion, two equal lines look different lengths and the error survives even after you measure them, so your brain is adding something the input does not contain.
- Gibson's theory leaves almost no room for expectation, whereas Gregory's top-down theory treats it as central.
- The Necker cube is a single, unchanging line drawing, yet as you stare your perception flips between two 3D orientations.
- The input never changes, so it must be the brain, not the input, deciding what you see.
Culture
- People from different cultures can perceive the same scene differently, which direct perception cannot explain if the input is identical for everyone.
- People who grow up with little exposure to flat pictures or to rooms full of straight edges tend to experience some illusions less strongly than people raised among them.
- Because the light entering the eye is the same, the difference must come from cultural experience shaping perception, not from the input alone.
- State the argument against as the spec puts it: Gibson ignores the influence of expectation and culture.
- You do not have to reject Gibson; most psychologists argue both bottom-up and top-down processing are needed.
Making the Argument in the Exam
- State Gibson's claim: perception is direct, straight from the input.
- Give the counter: it ignores expectation and culture, which both change what people perceive.
- Back it with an example, such as reading a scrawled note or a cultural difference in experiencing an illusion.
- What two influences does Gibson's theory ignore?
- How does reading a scrawled note show the role of expectation?
- How can culture change what someone perceives?
- Why does this weaken a purely direct theory?