Skip to content

Course home

Revision guides·3.3.5 Argument against social identity theory
Sign up

3.3.5 Argument against social identity theory

The Limits of Social Identity Theory

  1. Social identity theory says helping flows from which group someone belongs to.
  2. But two people in the very same group often help to very different degrees.
  3. So group identity alone cannot be the full explanation of prosocial behaviour.
Key Idea
  • Individual differences within a group are not explained by social identity theory.
  • Cultural differences in helping also sit outside the theory.

Individual Differences Within Groups

  1. Social identity theory tends to treat all in-group members as if they will act alike.
  2. Yet within one group, a caring person helps readily while a selfish person does not.
  3. This personality gap is left unexplained by a theory built only on group membership.
Example
  • Two Arsenal fans stand by a collapsed stranger in a Gunners shirt; one rushes to help while the other just films it.
  • Their shared identity is identical, so the difference must come from personality, not the group.

Cultural Factors

  1. Social identity theory was developed mainly from research in Western cultures.
  2. Some collectivist cultures raise everyone to help widely, not just their in-group.
  3. The theory struggles to explain that broad helping, so its account looks culturally narrow.
Common Mistake
  • Do not reject the theory; it explains in-group helping very well.
  • Do argue that personality and culture add causes the theory leaves out.

Building the Argument

  1. State the against as a plain point: group identity is not the only cause, since members of the same group help to different degrees.
  2. Name the rival level and back it, personality (a caring versus selfish in-group member) or culture (some raise people to help widely).
  3. Pair this against with Levine as the 'for', since giving only one side caps a four-mark for-and-against answer at three.
Self review
  • What is the main argument against social identity theory?
  • How do individual differences within a group challenge it?
  • Why might the theory look culturally narrow?
  • What is the balanced conclusion?
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 3.3.5 Argument against social identity theory by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

7 minute activity

Start lesson

Social identity theory explains prosocial behaviour partly through group membership. People are more likely to help someone they see as part of their in-group.

However, group identity cannot be the complete explanation because members of the same group may help to very different degrees. Individual personality and cultural background can also influence helping.

A balanced evaluation does not reject the theory. It argues that the theory explains in-group helping well, but leaves out other important causes.

Questions

Put it into practice with exam-style questions

12 exam-style questions

Practice questions

Question 1

4 marks

A researcher reports an observation from a collectivist community where children are taught to assist anyone who needs help. Adult residents were just as likely to assist someone from another village as someone from their own village.

Explain how this example supports the argument against social identity theory of prosocial behaviour.

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

20 flashcards

Practice flashcards

What is the main argument against social identity theory?

3.3.5 Argument against social identity theory Revision Guide

  1. IGCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /3.3.5 Argument against social identity theory

Revision notes for CIE IGCSE Psychology 3.3.5 Argument against social identity theory: explanations and worked examples.

More revision guides