Levine et al.'s Study
- Social identity theory predicts you help people you see as part of your in-group more than outsiders.
- Levine et al. tested this with Manchester United fans, varying the shirt an injured stranger was wearing.
- This is the named study you use to argue for the theory, so lock down its results and conclusion.
- The one thing changed was the injured stranger's shirt: the fan's own team, a rival, or plain.
- Whether that shared identity changed helping is the whole point of the study.
What Levine et al. Found
- The stranger in a Manchester United shirt was helped most of the time.
- The stranger in a rival (Liverpool) shirt or a plain shirt was helped far less often.
- There was no real difference between the rival and plain shirts; what mattered was whether the shirt marked the stranger as in-group.
- Picture the jogger clutching his ankle in a Manchester United shirt as a United fan walks past.
- Most United fans stopped to help, treating him as one of their own; in a Liverpool or plain shirt he was mostly walked past.
What It Shows
- Levine et al. concluded that people are more likely to help those they recognise as in-group members.
- Because helping tracked the shared team identity rather than the person, it supports in-group favouritism.
- So the study is direct evidence for social identity theory's account of prosocial behaviour.
- A named study is examined on its results and its conclusion, never its aim or procedure.
- Here that means who was helped most (result) and that shared identity increases helping (conclusion).
Turning This Into an Argument
- Give the result: fans helped the Manchester United shirt most, and the rival and plain shirts far less.
- State the conclusion: helping tracked shared identity, direct evidence for in-group favouritism and social identity theory.
- That result-to-conclusion is all that scores; writing what Levine varied or how the study ran earns nothing.
- Who was most likely to be helped in Levine et al.'s study?
- Was there any difference between the rival shirt and the plain shirt?
- What did they conclude about in-group members?
- How does this support social identity theory?