The Limits of the Biological Explanation
- Even the twin studies that support biology never reach 100 per cent heritability.
- Whatever is left over must come from the environment rather than from genes.
- So you can argue that biology explains only part of why people help.
- Heritability is not entirely responsible for prosocial behaviour.
- Social groups and the roles you take on shape how much you help.
Where the Environment Takes Over
- You learn to help by copying the people around you, such as family, teachers and friends.
- The social roles you are given carry expectations that push you towards helping.
- Because these influences change with your situation, they cannot be traced to a fixed set of genes.
- A Year 12 pupil made a prefect suddenly starts helping younger students find their classrooms.
- Their genes have not changed in a term, so the new helping comes from the role, not from biology.
Why the Biological Account Falls Short
- The same person helps a teammate but may walk past a stranger, which shows the situation matters.
- If helping were down to genes alone, it would not swing so much with your role, your group or the situation you are in.
- Helping also varies between social groups and cultures, which points to learned, environmental influences rather than genes alone.
- Do not throw biology out; the twin evidence shows genes do play a part.
- Do argue that a full explanation needs the environment as well, so both nature and nurture count.
Building the Argument
- State the against as a plain point: heritability is never total, so the rival level, environment and upbringing, must also shape helping.
- Back it with one concrete environmental influence, such as a learned social role or the norms of a group you belong to.
- Pair this against with Rushton as the 'for', since giving only one side caps a four-mark for-and-against answer at three.
- Why does a heritability below 100 per cent weaken a purely biological account?
- Give one way a social role can increase helping.
- Why does helping changing with your role or group point to the environment?
- What is the balanced conclusion about nature and nurture?