Skip to content

Course home

Revision guides·3.2.8 Argument against biological explanation
Sign up

3.2.8 Argument against biological explanation

The Limits of the Biological Explanation

  1. Even the twin studies that support biology never reach 100 per cent heritability.
  2. Whatever is left over must come from the environment rather than from genes.
  3. So you can argue that biology explains only part of why people help.
Key Idea
  • Heritability is not entirely responsible for prosocial behaviour.
  • Social groups and the roles you take on shape how much you help.

Where the Environment Takes Over

  1. You learn to help by copying the people around you, such as family, teachers and friends.
  2. The social roles you are given carry expectations that push you towards helping.
  3. Because these influences change with your situation, they cannot be traced to a fixed set of genes.
Example
  • A Year 12 pupil made a prefect suddenly starts helping younger students find their classrooms.
  • Their genes have not changed in a term, so the new helping comes from the role, not from biology.

Why the Biological Account Falls Short

  1. The same person helps a teammate but may walk past a stranger, which shows the situation matters.
  2. If helping were down to genes alone, it would not swing so much with your role, your group or the situation you are in.
  3. Helping also varies between social groups and cultures, which points to learned, environmental influences rather than genes alone.
Common Mistake
  • Do not throw biology out; the twin evidence shows genes do play a part.
  • Do argue that a full explanation needs the environment as well, so both nature and nurture count.

Building the Argument

  1. State the against as a plain point: heritability is never total, so the rival level, environment and upbringing, must also shape helping.
  2. Back it with one concrete environmental influence, such as a learned social role or the norms of a group you belong to.
  3. Pair this against with Rushton as the 'for', since giving only one side caps a four-mark for-and-against answer at three.
Self review
  • Why does a heritability below 100 per cent weaken a purely biological account?
  • Give one way a social role can increase helping.
  • Why does helping changing with your role or group point to the environment?
  • What is the balanced conclusion about nature and nurture?
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 3.2.8 Argument against biological explanation by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

7 minute activity

Start lesson

Biological explanations argue that biological factors, including genes, may help explain prosocial behaviour such as helping others. Twin-study evidence, however, does not show that genetic differences explain all observed variation in prosocial behaviour. Heritability estimates can vary by trait, population and study.

A heritability estimate below 100 per cent indicates that genetic differences do not account for all the observed variation, but it does not by itself establish an environmental explanation. The remaining variation could reflect environmental influences such as upbringing, social learning, roles and group norms, as well as measurement error, sampling effects, non-additive genetic effects, non-genetic biological factors and gene-environment interaction. Therefore, the evidence challenges a complete genetic explanation, but it does not rule out biological influences more broadly.

A balanced conclusion is that prosocial behaviour may reflect genetic, other biological and environmental influences, while also recognising the methodological limits of heritability estimates.

Questions

Put it into practice with exam-style questions

25 exam-style questions

Practice questions

Question 1

4 marks

Researchers gave adult twin pairs a questionnaire about how often they helped their neighbours. Each person received a helpfulness score out of 20. A smaller mean difference between the scores within a twin pair shows greater similarity.

Twin typeMean difference between scores within each pair (points)
MZ1.4
DZ3.1

The researchers estimated that genetic differences accounted for 36% of the variation in helpfulness scores.

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

20 flashcards

Practice flashcards

What limitation do twin studies supporting biology share?

3.2.8 Argument against biological explanation Revision Guide

  1. IGCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /3.2.8 Argument against biological explanation

Revision notes for CIE IGCSE Psychology 3.2.8 Argument against biological explanation: explanations and worked examples.

More revision guides