A client gives three therapists the same report of a dream in which the client is standing on a stage and speaking into a microphone that produces no sound. Each therapist interprets the dream independently.
| Therapist | Opinion held before reading the dream report | Interpretation of the silent microphone |
|---|---|---|
| Amara | Dreams mainly reflect worries about achievement | The client fears being unsuccessful at work |
| Hughes | Dreams mainly reflect difficulties in family communication | The client feels unable to speak openly to their family |
| Chen | Dreams mainly reflect concerns about social judgement | The client fears that friends will not listen to them |
Explain how the information in the table shows an argument against the psychodynamic theory of dreaming and why this makes the theory difficult to test scientifically.
111 exam-style questions on CIE IGCSE Psychology 2.4 Psychodynamic theory of dreaming, covering 2.4.1 Parts of the mind, 2.4.2 Types of dream content, 2.4.3 Wish fulfilment, 2.4.4 Mechanisms of dreamwork, 2.4.5 Process of dream analysis, 2.4.6 Argument for psychodynamic theory of dreaming, 2.4.7 Argument against psychodynamic theory of dreaming, and 2.4.8 Application of psychodynamic theory of dreaming. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.