Evidence before certainty
Text One: The totals we could not compare
An original account by a student taking part in a survey of a fictional local stream.
On our first survey morning, I arrived expecting to discover how polluted the stream was. The section behind the playing field looked untidy, and within minutes I had photographed a bright drinks wrapper caught beneath a branch. It seemed like the perfect image for our report.
We divided into pairs and counted litter along the bank. I recorded each torn piece of a plastic bag separately because I could see six pieces. Another student counted a broken container as one object because it had once been a single item. A third pair listed only the rubbish they could safely reach and remove. When we compared totals, we argued about which stretch was worst without noticing that our numbers had been produced in different ways.
The following week, heavy rain had raised the water. Part of our original section was difficult to reach, so we moved further downstream. We found more litter there and began writing that the problem had increased. Our project leader asked whether we had inspected the same place under the same conditions. We had not. The two totals were accurate records of what we had counted, but they did not provide the comparison we thought they did.
My first draft claimed that local people did not care about the stream. The evidence did not show this. We had seen discarded objects, but we did not know who had dropped them or how far the water had carried them. An overflowing bin stood near one path, while several items were tangled in branches far from any entrance. These details might suggest explanations, but none proved a single cause.
For the next visit, we marked a fixed twenty-metre section. We agreed what would count as one item, used the same categories and noted the weather, water level and any place we could not inspect. We photographed the same points rather than only the most dramatic objects. One old shoe did not fit our categories neatly, so we recorded it in a note instead of forcing it into the wrong total.
Our final report was less certain than my first draft, but it was more useful. It stated where and when we had worked, explained the counting method and admitted that one short section could not represent the whole stream. We also described the safety boundaries: we wore gloves, stayed out of the water and stopped when the bank became slippery.
I had wanted our project to produce a powerful conclusion. Instead, it taught me that trustworthy evidence begins with decisions which can be explained and repeated.
Text Two: A responsible survey shows its limits
An original contribution by a project adviser supporting the fictional stream survey.
Begin with a question which your observations can answer. A survey of a defined section may show what was present there at a particular time. It cannot automatically establish the condition of an entire waterway or explain how every object arrived.
Agree the method before counting. Surveyors need shared boundaries, categories and rules for unusual cases. If one person counts every fragment while another reconstructs fragments into a single object, their totals cannot be compared fairly. Record inaccessible areas rather than pretending they were inspected.
Conditions matter. Rainfall, water level, recent maintenance and the time of the visit may affect what can be seen. Repeating a survey is most informative when the same location and method are used. Where this is impossible, identify the change instead of presenting unlike observations as a simple trend.
Separate observation from interpretation. A food container beside the stream is evidence that the container was there. It is not proof of who left it, why it was left or whether people in the whole neighbourhood behave carelessly. Possible explanations can be discussed, but they should be labelled as possibilities and tested against other evidence.
Do not remove awkward results merely because they weaken a neat pattern. An unusual item, an interrupted count or a total which differs from expectations may reveal a weakness in the categories or a question for later investigation. Clear notes allow readers to judge the evidence rather than simply trust the surveyors' confidence.
Protect both participants and the place being studied. Set boundaries for safe access, use suitable protective equipment and stop when conditions change. Obtain any necessary permission, avoid identifying or blaming individuals without evidence and do not damage the site in an attempt to inspect it.
A responsible report does more than announce a total. It explains the question, method, conditions and limitations, then suggests a proportionate next step. Evidence becomes more valuable when another group could understand how it was gathered and repeat the work.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a speech to students who are about to join the stream-monitoring project described in the texts. Advise them how to gather trustworthy evidence and communicate responsible conclusions.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.