What should grow together?
Text One: The beans in the compost
An original account by a young member of a fictional neighbourhood allotment association.
My plot is an awkward triangle beside the fence. It would never appear in a gardening magazine, but I know where the sun reaches first and which corner stays damp. Last year, I planted purple beans from seeds my grandmother had kept. I left some pods on the plants so that I could collect their seeds rather than eat them.
During a communal work day, the label beside the beans blew away. Another member saw the dry-looking plants and cleared them into the compost. He was trying to help. I had not told anyone what I was doing, and he had no reason to recognise that the untidy row was still useful. However, the mistake made me wonder what would happen if all our individual plots became shared growing areas, as the committee now proposes. In a shared garden, one person’s careful experiment might look like another person’s unfinished job.
That same afternoon also showed me what sharing can achieve. An experienced grower taught me how to repair a leaning support, and I borrowed tools I could not have bought for myself. Our present arrangement can leave beginners working alone behind separate fences. It also keeps people on a waiting list even when some plot-holders are temporarily unable to manage all their ground.
Sharing the work would not mean that everyone could follow the same timetable. I have a Saturday job and often visit near the end of the day. A compulsory weekend rota would make me appear unreliable, although I could water on weekday evenings, update planting records or prepare labels at home. Fair participation should recognise different contributions instead of rewarding only the most visible work.
A redesigned site could improve access. When my mother was recovering from an ankle operation, she could not reach my plot along the narrow, muddy path, but she could tend the waist-high containers near the shed. Wider paths, seating and raised growing spaces would help more people take part. They would be wasted, though, if all decisions were made at meetings that some members could not attend.
I am not against changing the allotment. I would support large shared beds if there were also clearly marked spaces where members could protect a particular plant or experiment. Before any fences come down, we need to know who may clear a bed, how tasks will be recorded and what happens to the harvest. Goodwill matters, but goodwill did not save my beans.
Text Two: Before the fences come down
An original article by the secretary of the fictional neighbourhood allotment association.
Our site contains 24 individually managed plots, while 11 people are waiting for one. At the autumn review, four plots had been largely unused for at least three months. Those figures reveal a problem, but not its cause. A member may be ill, caring for someone or facing a temporary change in working hours. Empty ground should not automatically be treated as proof that its holder no longer cares.
Shared growing areas could allow members to take on as much work as they can manage at a particular time. They could also reduce unnecessary duplication of tools and give inexperienced gardeners regular contact with people who can advise them. Nevertheless, removing fences will not distribute responsibility by itself.
Our existing communal fruit area provides a warning. Of 30 scheduled watering turns last summer, 19 were completed by the same three volunteers. The instruction to “take a fair share” of the fruit caused further disagreement: some members collected produce early in the week, while those who could only visit at weekends found little left. The fruit belonged to everyone in theory, but the work and rewards did not feel equally shared.
Any new arrangement therefore needs agreed rules. Members should know how planting choices are made, how unfinished tasks are identified and who may decide that a crop should be removed. Labels and a current site plan would protect plants being grown for seed or for a less familiar use. A mixture of common beds and smaller reserved spaces could preserve some individual choice without returning to 24 enclosed plots.
The work should be organised flexibly. Watering and digging are important, but so are keeping records, repairing equipment, ordering seeds and communicating with members. A person’s contribution should not be judged only by physical strength or by whether it happens during a public work day. The layout should also include firm, wide paths, raised containers and places to rest.
Members should vote on a complete scheme rather than on the attractive phrase “shared garden”. Before the vote, the committee should circulate a proposed layout, draft rules for work and harvests, and a list of materials required. Discussions should take place at more than one time, with a written way to respond for those unable or unwilling to speak at a meeting. Current members and people on the waiting list may have different priorities, but both groups need to understand what membership would involve.
The association has an opportunity to use its ground more generously. It also has a duty to avoid transferring every difficult task to a dependable few or allowing majority preferences to crowd out unusual plants. Sharing will succeed only if responsibility, choice and produce are shared in practice.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a speech to deliver at the allotment association’s annual meeting, recommending what members should decide about the proposal to replace individual plots with shared growing areas.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.