Who gets the harvest?
Text One: The sauce and the pears
An original account by a volunteer at a fictional community garden.
At the end of summer, our youth club planned to make lunch from vegetables grown in the community garden. We had watched the tomatoes turn red all week. When we arrived on Saturday morning, however, every ripe one had gone.
Leon, a volunteer, had picked them the previous evening. He had watered the plants through several hot days and was concerned that the heavy rain in the forecast would damage the fruit. He made a large batch of sauce and delivered jars to residents who could not easily visit the garden. His choice was not selfish, but our club still had to buy tomatoes for the lunch we had promised.
After that, the garden organisers began reserving particular crops for planned activities. The system appeared to work until the autumn family day was cancelled. Several boxes of pears had been left on the trees for the event. Although the cancellation was announced, nobody decided whether the reservation had ended. By the following weekend, many pears had fallen and become too damaged to distribute.
The two harvests changed my idea of fairness. In one case, useful food reached the neighbourhood, but one person decided its purpose without consulting those who had expected it. In the other, everyone respected a plan long after it had ceased to be useful. Neither taking food quickly nor protecting it indefinitely produced a completely fair result.
A harvest cannot wait while people debate every tomato or pear. Even so, decisions about shared food should not depend entirely on who arrives first, who has worked the most hours or which label happens to remain attached to a tree.
Text Two: Fair shares are not always equal shares
An original account by the coordinator of another fictional community garden.
Community gardens often have several aims at once. They may provide food for volunteers, supply organised activities and offer something to the surrounding neighbourhood. Problems arise when one of these purposes is treated as the only one that matters.
Simple rules can sound fair while favouring particular people. Giving the harvest to those who have worked the most hours overlooks contributions such as raising seedlings at home, lending equipment or delivering produce. Allowing anyone to take food on a first-come basis benefits people with flexible schedules. Dividing every crop equally can produce portions too small to be useful.
Our garden agrees broad priorities at the beginning of each growing season, but it does not set rigid quantities months in advance. Crops do not become ready in equal amounts or exactly when a group expects them. Each week, a small rotating team decides what should be used immediately, what can support a planned activity and what can be offered more widely.
Reserved produce has a collection time. If a group no longer needs it or cannot collect it, the food is reassigned rather than left unused. A simple harvest record shows what was picked and where it went. When there is an unusually large crop, we contact a nearby lunch project. When very little is ready, we honour specific commitments instead of pretending that everyone can receive an equal share.
These decisions will not satisfy every person on every occasion. However, a rotating decision-making team prevents control from remaining with the same few volunteers, while the record allows the wider group to question patterns over time. Fairness is not a perfect division of each basket. It is a process which recognises effort, keeps promises where possible and changes course before good food is wasted.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a letter to the editor of a local newspaper giving your views on what fair sharing should mean in community gardens and how harvested food can be kept from going to waste.
Your letter should consider:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.