Skip to content

Course home

Question bank·2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts
Sign up

2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts

MediumHard
123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101102103104105106107108109110111112113114115116117118119120121122123124125126127128129130131132133134135136137138139140141142143144145146147148149150151152153154155156157158159160161162163164165166167168169170171172173174175176177178179180181182
Question 64

Who gets noticed?

Text One: The cup with my name on it

An original account by a student who received a school award.

At the start of the year, our headteacher announced the Good Neighbour Cup. Any pupil could nominate someone for a contribution made outside lessons. A shortlist would be displayed in the main corridor and the whole school would vote. It sounded fair because everyone had a voice.

My nomination came from the school open evening. I had stood beside the main entrance, greeting families and directing them to different rooms. It was enjoyable work and extremely visible. By the end of the evening, dozens of visitors had spoken to me.

Farah’s work had begun three weeks earlier. She read the requests sent in by visitors, persuaded the organisers to move one presentation downstairs and produced a large-print room list. She also arranged breaks for the guides. When a stack of spare chairs blocked one of the planned routes, she found someone to move them before most visitors arrived. Families benefited from her decisions without knowing her name.

The nomination form allowed only one sentence explaining each choice. I received several versions of ‘welcomed everyone with a smile’. Farah received two nominations. When the shortlist appeared, the paragraph beside my photograph claimed that I had helped to organise the entire welcome. I asked whether it could mention the team, but voting had already begun and a teacher said that the award was only meant to celebrate a positive example.

I won. During the assembly, the headteacher praised me for planning an accessible event. I tried to explain that Farah had designed the routes. The assembly leader immediately invited her onto the stage to share the applause. Farah came forward, but afterwards she told me that being singled out without warning had made her deeply uncomfortable.

She did not want her work ignored. She would have valued an accurate message thanking the whole team, and she wanted the school to pay for permanent signs so that the improved routes could be used again. Public applause was not the only form of recognition available, she argued, and it was not automatically the most useful.

My name is still engraved on the cup. Farah’s route plan is still being used. The experience made me wonder whether our award had discovered the most valuable contribution or simply the person whose contribution had been easiest to see.

Text Two: Recognition should tell the truth

An original article by a coordinator of youth projects.

Recognition does more than reward past effort. It shows a community which actions it values and can influence what people volunteer to do next. A poorly designed scheme may encourage highly visible activity while overlooking preparation, prevention and quiet reliability.

Popularity is not evidence of impact. Instead of asking nominators simply to name a deserving person, ask them to identify an action, its effect and anyone else involved. Keep the process brief enough to use, but require more than general praise. Twenty vague nominations should not automatically outweigh one detailed account.

Published criteria can make decisions easier to understand. A small panel of students and staff could consider the evidence against those criteria, rather than counting votes. Membership of the panel should change regularly, and anyone with a close connection to a nomination should step aside from that decision. These safeguards will not remove every disagreement, but they reduce the influence of reputation and favouritism.

Individual and team recognition are not opposites. A report can credit one person’s particular initiative while also naming the people whose less obvious work made it possible. Panels should be cautious about relying only on hours completed: a short action may solve an important problem, while a long attendance record does not explain what was achieved.

The person being recognised should have some choice about the form it takes. Possibilities include a private letter, a public account of the contribution, recognition for a whole team or practical support for the work to continue. Permission should be sought before publishing personal details or calling someone onto a stage.

Some people fear that wider recognition turns into meaningless praise for everyone. Others believe that a single winner makes an award exciting. There is a better distinction to make. Specific thanks can be given to many people without pretending that every contribution is identical, while limited resources or special opportunities can still be awarded where the evidence justifies them. Public ranking, however, may encourage campaigning rather than service.

No system should be treated as finished after its launch. Run it for a term, ask participants which contributions remain overlooked and find out whether recipients valued the recognition they received. If the same highly visible names appear repeatedly while whole areas of work remain absent, the process needs changing. A fair scheme does not merely produce louder applause; it produces a more accurate account of how a community succeeds.

Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.

Write a speech for a meeting of students and staff, proposing a new school system for recognising contributions made outside lessons. Persuade your audience that recognition can be both meaningful and fair.

You should include:

  • weaknesses revealed by the experience of the Good Neighbour Cup and why they matter
  • a fair and workable way to identify contributions and decide who should be recognised
  • suitable forms of recognition and a method for reviewing the new system

Shape your speech for its mixed audience and persuasive purpose.

[30]
Markscheme

2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts Questions

  1. IGCSE
  2. /English Language
  3. /2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts

212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.

More questions