Light where it is needed
Text One: Before the first bus
An original account by an early-shift worker responding to a fictional street-lighting trial.
My shift at the bakery begins at five in the morning. I leave home at 4.20 a.m. and walk through three residential streets to the first bus. During the council’s trial, selected lamps were reduced between 12.30 a.m. and 5.30 a.m. The notice called these the quietest hours. For me, they are the beginning of the working day.
On the first morning of the trial, two wheelie bins had been left partly across the pavement. I stepped towards the road to pass them and heard a bicycle bell before I had seen the cyclist. Later that week, heavy rain covered the edge of the kerb. Nothing terrible happened, but I began taking a longer route along the High Street, where the shopfronts and crossings were brighter. That adds twelve minutes to a journey which is already made before most people wake.
I am not asking for every lamp to shine at full strength throughout the night. On my way home, I pass a locked depot yard which remains brightly lit even when it is empty. Meanwhile, the corner beside my bus stop was included in the dimming trial. That does not look like careful use of light; it looks like a rule applied without enough attention to where people actually go.
The council should identify a dependable network of overnight walking routes. Crossings, bus stops, sharp corners and links used by early workers could remain clearly lit, while lamps in less-used places could be reduced. Broken lights must also be separated from deliberately dimmed ones when the trial is assessed. A failed lamp beside a lowered lamp can leave a whole section unexpectedly dark.
I heard about the public meeting, but it began at 6.30 p.m., when I was asleep before my next shift. If the council wants to understand the town after midnight, it must ask people who are awake then. A short survey at the bus station before the first departures would reveal more than a meeting filled only with people who keep daytime hours.
Text Two: The lamp outside my curtains
An original account by a resident supporting changes to a fictional town’s overnight lighting.
A street lamp stands directly opposite my upstairs window. Before the trial, its light reached across the road, through the curtains and onto the bedroom wall. During the weeks when its output was reduced after 12.30 a.m., the room was noticeably darker. The pavement did not disappear. There was still a steady pool of light outside, but far less of it entered the house.
That experience made me support reducing unnecessary overnight lighting. However, the trial also showed how badly a sensible idea can work when every location is treated alike. One night I returned from caring for my aunt at 1.15 a.m. The lower lighting along my street was comfortable to walk under, but the lamp at the pedestrian crossing had stopped working completely. The sudden dark patch mattered more than the general reduction.
The choice should not be presented as either flooding every street with light or turning the town black. Some lamps could be fitted or adjusted so that they direct light onto the pavement instead of bedroom windows. A lower, steady setting may suit a residential street, while crossings and transport stops require a different approach. The empty sports-centre car park near my home also stayed fully illuminated throughout the trial, even though its gates were locked. The council should examine such inconsistencies before asking residents to accept a town-wide policy.
I was disappointed by the consultation form. It asked whether we wanted to ‘keep the present lighting’ or ‘adopt reduced lighting’. There was no space to distinguish between a lamp outside a bedroom, one beside a crossing and one in an unused car park. There was also no question about what time respondents travelled or why they were outdoors.
Before making the change permanent, the council should test more than one arrangement and publish what happened in particular places. Residents need to know where faults occurred, which routes remained in use and whether complaints concerned glare, poor visibility or broken equipment. Evidence grouped into one total will conceal the very differences that should shape the final plan.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a letter to the editor of a local newspaper discussing what the council should do about the proposal to reduce overnight street lighting.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.