A loan that helps someone begin
Text One: The instrument that stayed in its case
An original account by a young borrower using a fictional community instrument library.
When I returned the alto saxophone, the volunteer asked what I had enjoyed playing. I could not think of an honest answer. For most of the eight-week loan, the instrument had remained inside its case.
I had chosen it after hearing an experienced musician perform at the library’s launch. The sound filled the hall, and I wanted to create it myself. I held the saxophone briefly before signing the loan form, but nobody asked how I would carry it home, where I could practise or whether I had used a reed instrument before. I am glad the volunteer did not try to choose for me; however, a few practical questions might have made my choice more informed.
During the first week, the reed supplied with the instrument split. The general care card said to return every part and not attempt repairs, so I did not know whether replacing a reed was allowed. I sent a message and received a helpful answer six days later. By then, I had lost confidence and was worried that another ordinary problem might count as damage.
The return date also fell just after several weeks when the school practice room was being used for rehearsals. I asked for extra time and was given a fortnight. A friend borrowing from the same library had previously been told that loans could not be extended. Neither of us understood why the decisions were different. I did not want an extension simply because I had happened to ask the right person.
At the return appointment, the volunteer noticed a faint mark on the case. We both tried to remember whether it had been there at the beginning. No accusation was made, but the uncertainty was uncomfortable. A quick record made when the instrument was handed over would have protected both of us.
Before I left, I was invited to try a smaller stringed instrument. Five minutes of holding it, hearing its quieter sound and discussing where I could practise told me more than the original launch performance had done. I would borrow again if changing direction were treated as part of learning rather than as failure.
On paper, my saxophone loan lasted ten weeks and ended with every item returned. That record would not reveal how little playing took place, why I stopped or why I might still continue with a different instrument.
Text Two: A loan begins before the case leaves
An original report by the organiser of the fictional community instrument library.
The purpose of an instrument library is not merely to move instruments in and out of storage. It should give people a realistic opportunity to begin playing and to discover whether a particular instrument suits them.
An inspiring demonstration can attract new borrowers, but selection should also include a short conversation. Invite people to handle the closed case, consider transport and storage, and discuss when and where practice may be possible. Explain any materials that wear out through normal use. These questions should inform choice, not become a test of who deserves to borrow or an excuse to make assumptions about someone’s age, experience or background.
A brief group introduction can cover points common to every loan. It can then be followed by an individual checklist for the chosen instrument. This is more manageable than repeating a long explanation separately to each borrower, while still allowing important differences to be addressed.
The first choice will not always be the right one. An early exchange period can allow a beginner to change instruments without embarrassment. Loan extensions also need a published rule and a clear decision date. Where not every extension can be granted, use an agreed method such as a rotation date or ballot. Do not reward only the quickest person to send a message, and do not make musical skill a condition of receiving more time.
Care information must be specific enough to use. State which accessories belong to the library, which small materials may need replacing and what a borrower should do if something stops working. Where an essential material has a regular cost, either include an initial supply or explain the cost before the loan and provide a discreet route to support. A published time for answering routine questions can prevent borrowers from expecting immediate replies while allowing volunteers to deal with messages together.
At handover, the borrower and volunteer should check the case contents and note existing marks. A short written record or photograph of the instrument and case can prevent later disagreement. The return check should use the same record and distinguish missing parts from reasonable signs of use.
Follow-up should be brief but purposeful. An early question might ask whether the borrower has started playing, needs advice or wishes to change instruments. After the return, ask what helped, what prevented use and whether the person intends to continue. Do not demand recordings or proof of progress. Repeated reasons for stopping, successful changes of instrument and continued participation provide useful evidence for improving the next set of loans.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a letter to the person who runs the community instrument library, proposing how loans should work so that beginners get a worthwhile start, borrowers are treated consistently and people keep their confidence in the scheme.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.