A path which still leaves somewhere quiet
Text One: The bench before the water
An original account by a young resident responding to a fictional proposal for improved access to a neighbourhood pond.
My grandfather used to walk around the pond with me after Sunday lunch. The route was never smooth, but he knew where the ground stayed firm and which fallen tree made the best place to sit. Since he began using a walking stick, we rarely go beyond the entrance. After rain, the narrow path becomes slippery, and there is nowhere to rest before reaching the water.
The plan for a firm path and several seats could return the pond to him and make it usable by many other people who currently turn back. It might also help visitors notice more than the ducks nearest the gate. When people can spend time beside a place, they are more likely to value it.
Even so, I hesitate when the proposal describes a continuous broad walkway around the entire pond. Part of its character comes from not seeing every bank at once. A complete circuit could bring every conversation, bicycle and group activity close to areas which are now quiet. Improving access should not mean spreading the busiest part of the park everywhere.
Seating requires more thought than placing identical benches at equal intervals. Some visitors need a backrest or space beside them for a mobility aid. Others may want to sit away from a group. A viewpoint is useful only if planting, railings or people standing in front of it do not make the water impossible to see.
The pond is not tidy. Reeds lean across the edges, paths change with the weather and birds appear in different places. I do not want all of that controlled into a formal garden. Nor do I think leaving the path muddy proves that the place is natural. It simply decides which visitors can reach it.
I would welcome a route to one or two good viewpoints, suitable seats and clear information about where the path becomes more difficult. I would rather the council tested those changes than built around the whole pond at once. My grandfather does not need every metre made available before a visit can become possible again.
Text Two: Access should respond to the place
An original article by a manager of fictional public landscape projects.
Improving access to a natural space can allow more residents to enjoy it, learn from it and support its care. Poor surfaces, steep sections and a lack of resting places may exclude visitors long before an official notice does. Nevertheless, access should be planned in response to the particular site rather than delivered as the same path, seat and sign in every location.
Begin by identifying how the space is currently used. Observe entry points, busy periods, informal routes and places where people already pause. Seek advice about the condition of the site and any areas which may be vulnerable to increased disturbance. Consultation should include people who find the existing route difficult as well as those who use it frequently in its present form.
A complete circuit is not always necessary. A firm route to selected viewpoints may deliver substantial improvement while retaining quieter banks. Where routes continue over more difficult ground, clear information can help visitors make informed choices. Signs should be concise and placed where decisions are made, not added in such numbers that the landscape becomes a noticeboard.
Seats should be chosen and positioned for actual users. Some need arms or backs; some require adjacent space rather than an obstacle beside the path. Views, shade, surface level and distance from other seats all affect whether a resting place is useful. One standard design repeated without attention to location may satisfy a plan while failing visitors.
Construction is only the beginning. Surfaces wear, vegetation grows and drainage can alter after severe weather. If responsibility and funding for inspections are unclear, an accessible route may gradually cease to be accessible. Maintenance should therefore be included in the proposal rather than treated as a future problem.
A phased project allows assumptions to be tested. Open an initial section, observe how people use it and ask whether the route, seating and information work as intended. Review effects on both visitors and the quieter parts of the site before extending the scheme. Success is not measured by the greatest possible length of new path, but by whether access improves without needlessly erasing what people value about the place.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a letter to the manager of the park giving your views on the plan to improve access to the pond and suggesting how it should be carried out.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.