Help without taking over
Text One: The sentence I nearly supplied
An original account by a student volunteering as a peer study mentor.
I arrived at the homework room with highlighters, a paragraph plan and an example answer. I had prepared so thoroughly that I expected to begin teaching as soon as someone sat down.
The younger student placed an assignment on the table and said that she did not know how to start. I pointed to the first box on my plan and suggested an opening sentence. She copied it exactly. When I offered the next phrase, her pen waited above the page for me to continue. The work was becoming complete, but it was not becoming hers.
I put my plan aside and asked her to explain the assignment in her own words. She could not, so we read the instruction together and separated what she had to decide from the evidence she had to use. I asked her to choose one detail that seemed important. The silence which followed felt much longer to me than it probably did to her, but eventually she chose one and explained why.
After that, my questions became smaller. What does this example show? Which word supports your point? How could a reader misunderstand this sentence? When she became stuck on the conclusion, I demonstrated the method using a completely different topic, then asked her to apply it to her own work. She crossed out my suggested opening and wrote a better one.
Before leaving, she asked me to correct every sentence. Instead, I showed her one repeated punctuation problem and asked her to find the other examples. I also told the room coordinator that the assignment instructions had confused several students. I did not repeat the embarrassed comment she had made about being the slowest person in her class; it was not information the coordinator needed in order to improve the task sheet.
My paragraph plan was not useless. It reminded me of possible stages when the session lost direction. However, the most useful preparation was learning to notice whether the person beside me was thinking, or merely waiting for me to do the thinking.
Text Two: Support which builds independence
An original article by a coordinator of a student mentoring programme.
Begin a study session by agreeing a realistic purpose. Read the assignment, but also ask the learner what they have attempted and where the difficulty begins. Someone who says, ‘I cannot write this,’ may be uncertain about the instructions, the subject matter or only the first step. Assistance becomes more useful when the actual obstacle has been identified.
Use prompts which leave decisions with the learner. Ask for an explanation, a choice between possible approaches or the evidence behind an idea. Allow time for an answer instead of filling every pause. If a process needs to be demonstrated, use a separate example or complete only one stage before returning control. A mentor should make the next attempt possible, not make it unnecessary.
Check understanding by asking the learner to explain the method or apply it independently. Repeating the mentor’s words is not the same as understanding them. Feedback should also be selective. Identifying one pattern and helping the learner recognise further examples is usually more valuable than correcting an entire page without discussion.
Peer mentors have limits. They should not produce work which will be assessed as another student’s own, circulate somebody’s work or turn personal difficulties into conversation with friends. A mentor is also not responsible for resolving every problem. If instructions appear inconsistent, a learner becomes distressed or the requested help goes beyond the mentor’s role, involve the supervising member of staff.
End by reviewing what the learner can now do and deciding on a manageable next step. Successful support may produce less completed work during the session than simply giving answers. Its value appears when the learner can continue after the mentor has moved away.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a contribution to a school learning website with the title “Help without taking over”. Advise students volunteering as peer study mentors.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.