Feedback we can use
Text One: The comment in the margin
An original account by a student revising a piece of written work.
The comment said develop your explanation. I copied it carefully onto my target sheet and wrote the next paragraph in exactly the same way. I had recorded the advice without knowing what action it required.
When I asked my teacher, she pointed to a sentence where I had named a detail but left its significance unstated. She asked what I wanted a reader to understand from it. Saying the answer aloud helped me see the missing step, and I added two sentences rather than replacing the whole paragraph with something longer.
A week later, another piece came back with several comments. I wanted to respond to everything at once. Instead, we chose one issue I could work on during the lesson and another to remember for the next task. That made the advice feel possible to use rather than a record of everything I had failed to do.
The useful part was having time to try the change and check whether it had done what I intended. I did not need my teacher to write the replacement sentences for me. I needed enough explanation to make a decision and a chance to ask when I was unsure.
My target sheet now contains a short example in my own words. It is less tidy than the copied comment. It also reminds me of something I can actually attempt when I reach the same difficulty again.
Text Two: From comments to a next step
An original article by a teacher reflecting on feedback arrangements.
Feedback has a purpose beyond proving that someone has read the work. It should help a learner recognise a useful next step. The form may be a written comment, a conversation, a shared example or a question, depending on what needs to be understood.
More comments do not automatically create more progress. A detailed response can overwhelm a student who does not know where to begin. Identify priorities and make the intended action clear enough to attempt. This does not mean supplying an answer which the student can reproduce without understanding the decision behind it.
Plan time for a response where it is appropriate. A comment returned just before an unrelated task may be read and then set aside. An opportunity to revise a section, explain a choice or apply an idea in a new example can show whether the advice has been understood. Not every task requires a complete redraft.
Students also have a role. Encourage them to identify the part they do not understand, ask a specific question and explain what they changed. Teachers need manageable arrangements, so one-to-one discussion cannot be the answer to every uncertainty. A useful shared explanation can address a difficulty which several students have noticed.
Judge the system by what learners can do with the information, not merely by the quantity of ink or the appearance of a completed target sheet. Evidence of understanding may include an unsuccessful attempt followed by a clearer question. Responding to feedback is a process of making choices, not a ceremony of copying comments.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a letter to your headteacher recommending ways to make feedback on students’ work more useful and manageable.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.