A garden needs more than an opening day
Text One: The bed beside the bench
An original account by a student involved in a school growing project.
Thirty-one people put their names on our list at the first meeting. We carried trays into the courtyard, took photographs and argued cheerfully about what to plant. By the end of the month, four of us were still arriving regularly. We had planned the launch much more carefully than the ordinary Tuesdays which came after it.
The popular jobs were easy to fill. Everyone wanted to sow something or paint a sign. Less visible tasks belonged to nobody. On one Monday, three people watered the same tray because each assumed it was helpful. During a four-day break, no one checked it at all. Several young plants did not recover. A list of names had looked like a team, but it had not told anyone what to do or when to do it.
We eventually introduced a weekly rota with a specific task beside each pair of names. We kept a short record of what had been done and named an adult to contact if a pair could not attend. Before holidays, we agreed a separate plan instead of hoping that somebody would remember. The paperwork was not exciting, but it meant that the growing space depended less on whichever student happened to walk past.
We had also behaved as though the courtyard had been empty before our project arrived. Bags and tools narrowed a route across it, and two benches were moved without asking the students who used them at lunchtime. One student on crutches could reach the courtyard but not the bed behind its wooden border. After listening to complaints, we restored the benches, kept a broad paved route clear and placed a container where it could be reached from the paving. These changes reduced our growing area, but they made the space more genuinely shared.
Our harvest was modest. However, the project gave science classes material to observe, provided leaves and flowers for artwork and brought together students from different year groups. Some pupils came simply because they liked having a quiet, practical task at lunchtime. Those benefits mattered, although they were harder to photograph than a basket of produce.
If we began again, I would not try to fill the whole courtyard immediately. I would begin with one manageable section, protect the ways people already use the space and expand only when we had shown that we could care for it.
Text Two: Begin with the purpose, not the seed packet
An original article by the coordinator of community growing spaces.
A growing project should begin with a clear purpose. Producing food, supporting lessons, offering a calm shared activity and changing the appearance of a space are all reasonable aims, but they do not create identical plans. If every possible benefit is promised at once, even a useful project may later be judged as a failure.
A courtyard is not unused merely because it contains no garden. People may cross it, sit there, meet friends or value an open view. Observe these existing uses and ask current users what must be retained. Access should shape the project from the start: consider routes, the height and position of containers, the storage of tools and whether a range of people can take part in meaningful tasks.
Start with a limited, reversible pilot. This allows organisers to discover how much work can be sustained without surrendering the entire space to an untested idea. A named coordinator should oversee a task calendar, but responsibility should be shared. Plans are needed for routine weeks, absences and holidays, with a clear alternative when the person assigned to a task is unavailable.
Keep records which are useful rather than decorative. The number of names collected on the first day reveals enthusiasm, not reliability. Look instead at participation over time, whether necessary tasks are completed, whether different users can contribute and whether the project creates difficulties elsewhere. Feedback from people who use the courtyard without joining the garden is evidence too.
The amount grown can be recorded, but it should not automatically become the only measure of success. Conditions and results change over a season. A review conducted after a few bright weeks may reward novelty rather than good management. Use staged reviews to decide whether the project should continue unchanged, be adapted, expand or stop. A successful pilot is not one that has to become permanent; it is one that produces honest evidence for the next decision.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a report to your school leadership team about a proposal to convert part of a paved courtyard, currently used as a route and for lunchtime seating, into a student-managed growing space. Recommend whether the proposal should proceed, be modified or not go ahead.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.