Sharing useful things
Text One: The kit we nearly returned late
An original account by a teenager who borrowed equipment from a youth centre.
When my friends suggested joining the youth centre’s overnight trip, I nearly refused. I did not own the equipment on the list, and buying items for one weekend seemed wasteful. Then I discovered that the centre’s trial equipment library included camping kits.
Collecting ours felt surprisingly official. A member of staff opened the bag and asked us to check each item against a list. We were impatient to leave, so we glanced inside and said everything was there. At the campsite, we discovered that one torch did not work. We managed without it, but our rushed check suddenly seemed less efficient than the careful one we had avoided.
The kit offered more than free equipment. Sharing it made us plan who would carry each part and who would make sure it came back. I had expected borrowing to remove responsibility; instead, it gave us a responsibility to the next group. That mattered when one mug disappeared beneath a seat on our journey home. We found it, but only after the agreed return time was uncomfortably close.
I would borrow a kit again. Without it, I might not have joined the trip at all. However, the system depends on people checking equipment properly and returning it when promised. A friendly reminder helped us, but reminders cannot replace borrowers taking the agreement seriously.
The centre should continue lending useful items, although it should not attempt to provide everything. Some equipment needs explanation or supervision, and popular kits may not be available whenever someone wants them. Sharing works best when borrowers understand that access is a benefit they help to preserve for others.
Text Two: Report on the equipment-sharing trial
An original report by the coordinator of a fictional youth centre.
The eight-week trial offered three types of activity. Board-game sets and camping kits could be taken away, while the sewing machine was available only during a supervised weekly session. The figures below record all bookings during the trial.
| Activity | Bookings or loans | Completed as arranged | Users who said they would use it again |
|---|---|---|---|
| Board-game sets | 36 | 34 | 25 |
| Camping kits | 24 | 17 | 20 |
| Supervised sewing-machine sessions | 12 | 12 | 11 |
“Completed as arranged” means that a borrowed item was returned by the agreed time or that a user attended an on-site booking. Every user completed the feedback question.
The board games produced the largest number of loans and few late returns. However, eleven users did not say they would borrow them again. Several explained that they had already played the available games and would prefer a changing selection.
Camping kits received fewer loans, but most borrowers wanted to use them again. Their seven late returns created practical problems because a delayed kit could not be checked and prepared for the next booking. Staff spent more time following up these loans than any others.
The supervised sewing sessions had the fewest bookings, partly because only one machine and one session per week were available. Attendance was completely reliable, and eleven of the twelve users wanted another session. Some users said that supervision gave them confidence to try equipment they would not have used alone.
The trial budget for next term can fund either an additional supervised opening each week or the purchase of more items from the existing categories. It cannot fund both. Ending the trial would save staff time, but it would also remove opportunities from young people who cannot conveniently obtain equipment of their own.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a report for the management committee of the youth centre evaluating the equipment-sharing trial and recommending how it should operate next term.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.