A room for different kinds of work
Text One: The question at the back of the hall
An original account by a student who used a fictional school’s lunchtime study-room trial.
I went to the study room on its first day because I needed to prepare notes for a presentation. The rule card at the entrance said that the whole hall was for independent work: phones had to be silent and nobody could talk. Even the scraping of a chair sounded unusually loud.
For the first twenty minutes, the silence helped. I finished a page which I had been avoiding all morning. Then I found an instruction in my notes which I did not understand. The friend who could have helped me was sitting three seats away, but asking her would have broken the rule. I packed up and spoke to her outside. Another student left soon afterwards, although he said he had simply completed the short task he had brought. Time spent in the hall did not tell the whole story for either of us.
On the third day, a ‘question table’ was introduced at the back. Students could go there for a brief, quiet discussion before returning to individual work. This suited me: one answer from my friend allowed me to continue. However, sound travelled further than I had expected. Two students remained at the table discussing their weekend after solving their problem. A member of staff interrupted them, and the warning was more distracting than their first few whispers had been.
The table did not ruin the room, but it changed it. Some students now entered because they were allowed to ask for help; others moved towards the front to escape the conversations. On my exit slip, I could honestly say that I had completed my planned work. I could not say that the room had been as quiet as it was earlier in the week.
I would use the room again, although that does not mean its present arrangement is the best one. I sometimes need complete silence and sometimes need a quick explanation. The trial treated these as two needs which could share one hall. It had not yet shown whether they should.
Text Two: What the four-day trial recorded
An original summary and commentary by the fictional school’s study-room coordinator.
The room was open for the same 45-minute lunch period on four consecutive school days. The first two days used a whole-room silence rule. A question table operated inside the hall on the final two days.
| Day | Arrangement | Visits to the room | Visits lasting at least 20 minutes | Exit slips returned | Respondents saying the quiet helped them | Respondents saying they completed their planned work |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monday | Whole-room silence | 32 | 20 | 18 | 14 | 12 |
| Tuesday | Whole-room silence | 36 | 24 | 20 | 15 | 15 |
| Wednesday | Question table in the hall | 48 | 31 | 27 | 16 | 21 |
| Thursday | Question table in the hall | 50 | 30 | 25 | 13 | 18 |
These figures require cautious interpretation. A visit was counted each time someone entered, so a pupil attending on several days appears several times. Exit slips were voluntary. ‘Completed planned work’ was the pupil’s own judgement, and the tasks varied in length and difficulty. Leaving within twenty minutes might indicate dissatisfaction, but it might also mean that a short task had been completed efficiently.
The two arrangements were not alternated. The question table was used only on the later days, when different homework, activities or deadlines may have affected attendance. Consequently, the increase in visits cannot automatically be attributed to that table.
The trial nevertheless identifies questions worth investigating. Totals can show how much the room was used, while proportions can reveal whether the experiences reported by users changed. Comments also need to be separated: a pupil unable to ask for help has a different concern from one distracted by an extended conversation.
Before any arrangement becomes permanent, the school should test it for longer and collect more precise evidence. It should find out why people enter or leave, distinguish brief academic questions from social conversation and seek the views of pupils who chose not to use the room. A successful next stage would not merely attract more visits. It would establish which arrangement allows different pupils to complete the work they intended to do.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a report to the headteacher evaluating the four-day study-room trial and recommending what the school should do next.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.