Recognition beyond the total
Text One: The number beside my name
An original account by a student reflecting on a trial recognition scheme.
At the beginning of term, our school gave every student an activities card. Each approved after-school session earned one point. Monthly totals appeared on a noticeboard, identified by our initials, and the three students with the highest totals would receive prizes at the end of the trial.
At first, the card was useful. The list of approved sessions introduced me to activities I had not known existed. I went to the school garden team because one point seemed a small reward for trying something unfamiliar. By the third week, I no longer needed the point as encouragement: I liked working with the same group and seeing the changes we had made.
Then the totals were published. My seven points looked respectable until I saw totals above twenty. I began asking how many points an activity offered before asking what it involved. One afternoon, I chose two short drop-in sessions instead of the garden team. Nothing dishonest had happened, but the scheme had quietly changed the question I was asking. I was no longer deciding where I could contribute most; I was deciding how quickly I could move my initials upwards.
The points also made unlike contributions appear identical. Mina attended the garden team for six weeks, showed new members where equipment belonged and stayed when tidying took longer than expected. Another student attended six different introductory sessions. Both received six points. Trying a range of activities has value, but the matching totals could not show the different kinds of effort behind them.
Some students had fewer chances to collect points. My friend Arun regularly looked after his younger brother once lessons ended. He helped to prepare materials for a lunchtime group, but lunchtime work was not included in the trial. His low total suggested a lack of participation when the real difference was access to approved sessions.
This does not mean the card achieved nothing. Teachers could see which activities attracted new students, and one group was moved to lunchtime after several people said that they could not remain after school. A certificate for reaching a modest total also recognised many students without turning every one of them into a loser beneath three winners.
I would keep a record, but I would stop treating its total as a verdict. A number can begin a useful question: who has found an opportunity, who has been excluded and who might need an invitation? It becomes less useful when it claims to provide the complete answer to who contributed most.
Text Two: What can a point measure?
An original article by a youth programme organiser discussing participation and recognition.
Recognition schemes are often expected to perform two different jobs. One is to encourage people to take a first step into an activity. The other is to judge whose contribution deserves the greatest praise. A simple points system may help with the first job while being too crude for the second.
Points have genuine advantages. The rule can be published in advance, students can understand how recognition is earned and staff do not have to rely entirely on memory or on the most confident person drawing attention to their work. Participation records may also reveal that some sessions are inaccessible or that the same small group receives most opportunities.
However, an apparently objective total still depends on choices about what counts. One point for attendance records presence, not patience, initiative, improvement or support for others. Awarding more points for longer sessions would not solve every problem: it could simply favour students with more time available. Asking adults to score the quality of every contribution would create a different difficulty, because such judgements may be inconsistent.
Public rankings also alter the activity they measure. Competition may motivate some students, but it may discourage someone who joins late or whose total can never catch the leaders. Once prizes depend on quantity, students may reasonably choose several brief sessions over a sustained role. The scheme has then rewarded the behaviour its design encouraged, even if that behaviour was not its original purpose.
Schools do not have to choose between a leaderboard and complete silence. If the aim is to encourage participation, an achievable milestone can recognise everyone who reaches it. If the aim is to celebrate contribution, nominations from group members and leaders can be supported by brief examples of what the student did. Categories might recognise a first step, sustained commitment or help given to others instead of forcing every kind of contribution into one ranking.
Any evidence should remain proportionate. A long written reflection may reward confident writers rather than committed participants, so students could provide a short written or spoken explanation. Criteria should be published, decisions should involve more than one person and students should be able to understand why recognition was given.
Finally, treat the scheme itself as a trial rather than a finished answer. Offer activities at varied times, examine who can participate, ask students and leaders what the system changes, and revise it. Recognition is most credible when it directs attention towards valuable contribution without persuading students that value exists only when it can be converted into points.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a speech for a meeting of your school committee with the title “What should recognition recognise?”. Discuss the proposal to make the trial permanent, so that every approved after-school session earns one point, totals are published each month and prizes are given to the three students with the highest totals. Recommend whether the proposal should be adopted, rejected or revised.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.