Learning from one another
Text One: The session I nearly cancelled
An original account by a student who led a small skills workshop.
When our class was invited to teach one another a practical skill, I offered to demonstrate how to replace a missing button. I regretted volunteering as soon as my name appeared beneath the word “leader”. I could complete the task myself, but explaining each stage while other people watched felt entirely different.
At first, I arranged the chairs as if I were giving a lesson. Nobody chose the front row. The session improved when one student asked whether she could watch before attempting anything. Another offered to sort the thread and buttons rather than sew. Once these choices were available, the room felt less like a test.
I was not the only person with useful knowledge. One participant showed us a different way to secure the thread, so I invited him to demonstrate it. That moment changed my idea of leading: I did not have to behave as if everybody else knew nothing. By the end, two students who had arrived saying they were “bad at practical things” had completed the task.
There were problems. The workshop next door involved percussion, and its noise made quiet instructions difficult to hear. Our sign described me as a “student tutor”, which may have discouraged people who expected a formal lesson. Anyone arriving late had missed the first stage and could not easily join in.
Afterwards, the organisers collected positive feedback cards from everyone who had attended a session. However, nobody asked the students who stayed in the library or walked past our doors. The cards showed that many participants enjoyed themselves, but they could not show whether the event had offered a genuine choice to everyone.
Text Two: More than standing at the front
An original contribution by a member of a school planning group.
The school is considering a student-led skills afternoon. Students could share an activity they know well, support a session without presenting, attend workshops or choose a supervised quiet activity. Staff would be present, but students would take responsibility for explaining and organising the sessions.
A questionnaire produced the following results. Sixty students responded from each year group. Respondents could select more than one answer.
| Possible choice | Year 9 | Year 10 | Year 11 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Attend a student-led session | 44 | 39 | 31 |
| Offer to lead a session | 18 | 14 | 9 |
| Help to organise without presenting | 20 | 27 | 33 |
| Choose a supervised quiet activity | 14 | 22 | 34 |
The figures suggest interest, but they do not provide a complete plan. In every year group, more students would attend than would lead. The older respondents were less likely to offer a session, yet many were willing to organise behind the scenes. Their interest in a quiet alternative was also higher.
Some members of the planning group favour a compulsory programme so that every student tries something unfamiliar. Others argue that forced participation would contradict the purpose of recognising different abilities and preferences. A completely open choice presents another difficulty: popular sessions might fill immediately, while less confident students might follow their friends rather than select an activity for themselves.
For a trial, the school could accommodate up to 90 students in six classrooms over two workshop rounds. Each room would have a limit of 15 students. There is no budget for special materials, so proposed sessions would need to use school-owned or ordinary reusable items. A separate supervised room could provide quiet independent activity.
Success should not be judged only by counting attendance. The school could ask whether participants learned something, whether student leaders felt supported and whether the available choices felt genuine. It should also seek responses from students who applied but were not given a place, chose the quiet room or decided not to take part.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a report for the headteacher with the title “Learning from one another”. Evaluate whether a student-led skills afternoon would be worthwhile and recommend how a one-afternoon trial should be organised.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.