Text One: The rota everyone had read
An original account by a student helping to organise a youth market.
I was responsible for sharing the final stall rota for our youth market. Instead, I uploaded an earlier draft. It placed the pottery group in the morning, left out the magazine group and showed an arrival time which the organisers had already changed.
Twenty-six people had opened the file before I noticed. I replaced it and hoped that would solve the problem. It did not. People who had read the first version had no reason to look again. On Saturday, two groups arrived expecting the same stall, while the magazine group believed that its application had been rejected.
My first message said that several versions had been circulating. That was true, but it made the mistake sound as though it had appeared by itself. I sent another message stating that I had uploaded the wrong draft. I identified the corrected arrival time and explained where the single current rota could be found.
A general message could stop more people following the wrong information, but it could not repair every consequence. I contacted the affected groups directly. I did not name the magazine group publicly because I had not asked whether its members wanted others to know that they had been omitted.
There was no perfect way to restore the original plan. The pottery group had already arranged transport for the morning. Moving it would have transferred the inconvenience to people who had followed the rota they received. We offered the magazine group a later stall with more display space or a guaranteed place at the next market. Its members chose the later stall, although one could no longer attend.
For the next event, the organisers agreed to keep one dated rota in a shared location, archive drafts and ask a second person to check names and times before publication. These changes cannot recover the lost morning or make everyone trust my messages immediately. They can make another error less likely and give people a clear version to rely on.
Text Two: Correcting information without multiplying confusion
An original advice article by a contributor to a youth organisations website.
When inaccurate information has already influenced decisions, a correction has two jobs. It must prevent further misunderstanding and respond to the consequences for people who acted on the mistake. Quietly replacing a document may achieve neither, because readers may not know that anything has changed.
Make the accurate information easy to identify. State what has changed, label the current version and use the channels through which the error reached people. However, correcting something publicly does not require exposing every person affected or repeating private details. A direct conversation may be needed alongside a concise public update.
Give priority to people who have already spent time, changed arrangements or lost an opportunity because of the error. Ask what response would be useful rather than assuming that the most visible gesture is the fairest one. It may be impossible to remove every consequence. Where people’s needs conflict, explain the limits honestly and use clear reasons for the decision instead of favouring whoever complains most loudly or is easiest to accommodate.
Responsibility is weakened when an organiser hides behind phrases such as ‘there was some confusion’. Context can clarify how an error occurred, but it should not disguise who made the decision or who will now act. Equally, taking responsibility does not mean making promises which cannot be kept.
Future reliability depends on observable arrangements: one current source of information, clear version labels, a checking process and confirmation that important changes have reached the relevant people. These measures do not entitle an organiser to immediate trust. Confidence returns, if it does, through repeated evidence that information is accurate and that mistakes are handled openly.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write an article for a website used by people who run youth organisations, titled “When the wrong information has already travelled”, advising them how to respond when inaccurate information has changed other people’s plans.
You should include:
Make clear why the priorities you recommend are fair and effective.
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.