A plan people can improve
Text One: The square on paper
An original account by a teenager helping to plan a trial evening market.
At the first planning meeting, I arrived with a drawing of the town square covered in food stalls, strings of lights and a stage. I had even coloured in the crowds. To me, the drawing showed exactly why the market would be exciting. When other people raised questions, I thought they were trying to drain all the energy from the idea.
The organiser suggested that we walk around the square instead of continuing to argue over my sketch. A shopkeeper showed us the entrance where deliveries arrived. A resident pointed out the quickest route to the bus stop, which my line of stalls would have blocked. Another person explained that the uneven side of the square was difficult to cross with a wheelchair. These were not details I had noticed when I visited with friends, but they were part of how other people used the same place.
We revised the layout and agreed that the first market would be a trial. The stalls, signs, seating and small performance area could all be moved. During the evening, I helped record where queues formed and which routes remained clear. The market looked busy from the main entrance, but a row of craft stalls around the corner received few visitors because the signs were easy to miss. Near the performance area, several people said that conversation was difficult, while the seats placed farther away became a popular meeting point.
At the review meeting, we did not ask only whether people had enjoyed themselves. We asked which parts of the square they had visited, what had helped them find their way and what had made it difficult to stay. Stallholders, visitors, nearby residents and volunteers did not always agree, but their comments gave us practical choices to consider.
I still like lights, music and a lively crowd. I have simply stopped treating my first drawing as something that must be defended. A useful plan is not the one that survives every question unchanged. It is the one that becomes more workable because people were invited to question it.
Text Two: Test the event, not the audience
An original article by an organiser of community events.
An enthusiastic proposal can begin an event, but it cannot complete the planning. Public spaces already have users, routines and limitations. Before deciding where everything should go, planners should observe the place at relevant times and speak to people who move through it for different reasons.
Consultation should invite more than a simple vote for or against an idea. Ask focused questions. Which entrances must remain accessible? Where might a queue cause difficulty? At what time would noise become intrusive? What would help a visitor understand the layout? A person who identifies a problem is not necessarily opposing the whole event. The concern may reveal a change that allows more people to take part.
A trial is valuable because some effects cannot be predicted confidently in a meeting. Temporary signs, movable stalls and adjustable timings allow organisers to test choices without pretending that the first arrangement is permanent. During the event, volunteers can observe movement, waiting times, empty areas and points of confusion. They should also listen to people who attend, people working at the event and those affected nearby.
High attendance is encouraging, but numbers alone do not prove that every part of an event has worked. Visitors may crowd into one visible area while another is overlooked. A route may appear clear until a queue develops. People may enjoy the event while still identifying a problem with sound, seating or information.
Afterwards, organisers should compare observations with specific feedback and explain what will change before another event. They may not be able to satisfy every preference, but they should show that concerns have been considered rather than collected and forgotten. Consultation earns trust when people can see how their contribution affected the next decision.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a speech for a meeting of young residents, persuading them to take an active, thoughtful part in planning and reviewing the trial evening market.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.