Text One: The green apple at the bottom
An original account by a teenager helping at a fictional community orchard harvest.
The poster at the gate asked, “Can you find our finest apple?” Beside the words was a photograph of a large, polished red one. It made the harvest day look like a treasure hunt, and that was partly why my friends and I volunteered.
Within an hour, the red trees were surrounded. People held up their best-looking apples for photographs, while a row of smaller green apples remained almost untouched. I assumed they were not ripe. A volunteer called Mara explained that green was the natural colour of that variety and that the apples were ready to be cooked. The poster had brought plenty of willing hands into the orchard, but its idea of “finest” had quietly become a rule about what was worth picking.
I moved to the sorting shed, where the crates were labelled “store”, “use soon”, “press today” and “compost”. Fruit intended for storage needed to be firm and undamaged. A sound apple with an ugly surface mark could still be pressed that afternoon, while a glossy apple with a soft patch might be unsuitable. I began to understand that there was no single test for a good apple. Its condition and intended use both mattered.
Another sign offered a small prize to the team that collected the heaviest crate. The competition kept younger volunteers interested, but some teams filled their crates so quickly that storing apples, cooking apples and damaged fruit were mixed together. The sorters had to empty several crates and begin again. The teams had certainly worked hard; their target had simply encouraged them to notice weight before usefulness.
Near the end of the day, I heard three different suggestions for the harvest. One volunteer wanted more fruit sent to a community kitchen. Another argued that selling bottles of juice would pay for tools. A neighbour thought everyone who had helped should take a bag home. Each proposal sounded fair until it was placed beside the other two.
The organisers eventually filled the kitchen's requested crates, set aside apples for juice and offered volunteers fruit from a shared table. I did not win the prize or find the apple from the poster. My most useful job was writing destination labels for the crates. It was less impressive in a photograph, but it meant the harvest could actually be used.
Text Two: A harvest needs more than willing hands
An original article by a committee member at the fictional community orchard.
A public harvest day can turn an urgent seasonal job into a lively community event. New volunteers meet one another, children discover where fruit comes from and a large crop can be gathered before it spoils. However, an invitation does more than attract people: it influences what they believe their work is for.
Words such as “biggest”, “best” and “perfect” are easy to promote. They may also encourage people to treat varied fruit as a failed version of the same product. Our trees produce apples of different sizes and colours, and not every apple has the same destination. Fruit for storage, immediate cooking and pressing must be judged differently. Rotten fruit should not be disguised as useful, but neither should sound fruit be rejected because it would look ordinary in a photograph.
Simple targets can create energy. They can also reward the wrong result. A heavy crate is not much help if it contains fruit that must all be sorted again. On the other hand, a harvest day burdened with instructions can make new volunteers feel that they are taking an examination. A short demonstration, clearly labelled crates and a choice of jobs can provide enough structure without removing the pleasure of taking part.
Deciding where the harvest goes is equally important. Volunteers who have cared for the trees may reasonably expect to taste the crop. A community food project may be able to use a substantial quantity. Juice sales can fund future maintenance. Local residents may regard the orchard as a shared place whose produce should not disappear into one organisation. None of these interests automatically settles the question.
The committee should agree priorities before picking begins and explain them honestly. Fairness need not mean dividing every apple into equal portions. It means considering what different recipients can use, honouring promises already made and preventing the quickest group from claiming everything simply because it arrived first.
We should not judge the event only by attendance or by the total weight lifted from the trees. More useful questions are how much sound fruit reached an appropriate destination, whether unnecessary waste and repeated sorting were avoided, and whether inexperienced helpers learnt enough to contribute confidently. Enjoyment matters too: people are more likely to care for the orchard in future if they felt included in its work rather than used as free labour.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write an article for a youth magazine with the title “Which apple matters?” Discuss what young volunteers should understand about collecting and sharing fruit at a community orchard harvest.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.