A promise you can keep
Text One: The empty watering can
An original account by a teenager who agreed to organise a holiday watering rota.
At the meeting about the courtyard planters, I volunteered before anyone had finished describing the job. The community hall would be closed for two weeks, and somebody needed to organise volunteers to water the containers in its courtyard. I liked being the person who said yes while everyone else was still considering the problem.
I wrote ‘watering rota’ in my notebook but did not ask how often the planters needed attention, where the key was kept or which days the other volunteers could manage. I promised to arrange everything by Friday. Then I discovered that my family would be away for part of the holiday and that two volunteers had assumed I would contact them individually.
By Friday evening, I had produced half a list. I considered sending a message to explain, but I imagined everyone’s disappointment and decided to finish it the next morning. On Saturday, I forgot. Two days later, one of the volunteers visited the courtyard and found the watering can empty and several containers dry. She contacted the group and organised an emergency visit.
My first apology was mostly an explanation of how busy I had been. Nobody argued with it, which somehow made it worse. They had also been busy; they had simply not known that the rota was incomplete.
At the next meeting, I apologised again. This time, I named what I had failed to do and thanked the volunteer who had noticed the problem. We made one shared list containing the dates, names and key arrangements. I took two shifts which I knew I could attend instead of offering to manage the whole fortnight.
The planters recovered, but trust did not return because I gave a better speech. It returned gradually when I arrived for both shifts and sent the agreed confirmation afterwards. I still volunteer, although I now wait until I understand the task. A quick promise can sound generous; a realistic one is more useful.
Text Two: Reliability begins before you agree
An original article by a writer discussing promises and responsibility.
Promises are often made at the moment when enthusiasm is strongest and practical information is weakest. Agreeing immediately can appear helpful, but reliability depends on understanding what the commitment will require after that moment has passed.
Before answering, clarify the task. Ask what must be done, when it must be completed, who else is involved and what information or access you will need. Check your existing responsibilities. This is not a search for excuses; it is how you decide whether to accept the whole task, offer a smaller contribution or decline honestly.
Once you have agreed, make the commitment visible. Record dates, confirm arrangements and identify any stage which depends on another person. A private intention is not a plan shared by the people relying on you.
Circumstances can change. The responsible response is to communicate early, while others still have choices. State what has happened, explain which part of the commitment is affected and suggest a realistic alternative. Waiting until the deadline protects you from an uncomfortable conversation but transfers the difficulty to everyone else.
If a promise is broken, an apology should recognise the effect on other people rather than concentrating only on the reason for the failure. Take responsibility for the part you controlled, ask what would now be useful and avoid making a dramatic new promise simply to repair the moment.
Trust is usually rebuilt through repeated evidence. Completing a smaller agreed task, giving an accurate update or arriving when expected may matter more than an impressive declaration about the future. Reliability is not the ability to say yes to everything. It is the habit of making careful commitments and treating other people’s plans as real.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write an article for a youth magazine with the title “A promise you can keep”. Advise readers about making commitments responsibly and responding when plans go wrong.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.