A courtyard for more than one purpose
Text One: The plan looked better than the place
An original account by a student involved in redesigning a school courtyard.
At the beginning of the spring term, our survey asked whether the courtyard should be improved. Almost everyone answered yes, so I assumed we already agreed. At the first meeting, however, the word ‘improved’ began to divide us. I wanted a broad paved area with matching tables. Some students wanted a quiet place among plants. The site manager needed a route that would remain clear and a garden that could be maintained during school holidays.
The first proposal looked impressive on paper: straight paths, identical benches and hardly a leaf out of place. Before the committee voted on it, we borrowed large planters and movable chairs to mark out the design. For three lunch periods, students were invited to use the temporary layout.
They did not behave as our drawing suggested. The tables in the centre were crowded together, while two benches beside a busy doorway were almost always empty. A pupil using a wheelchair showed us that one turn in the proposed path was too tight. Other students moved chairs into smaller groups or carried them towards the quieter edge of the courtyard. The trial made the drawing less convincing, but the place itself became easier to understand.
I had also described a patch of tall, dry plants as neglected. Members of the ecology club explained that its seed heads provided food for birds and that insects could shelter in the stems. We kept part of the patch, gave it a low border and added a notice explaining its purpose. That did not make every overgrown area valuable, but it changed my idea of care. A garden could look intentional without being cut into perfect shapes.
By the final week of the summer term, the courtyard had a wide route, several kinds of seating and both planted and paved areas. It did not resemble one person’s finished picture. I preferred that. The most useful decisions had come from watching people adapt the temporary layout, not from defending the design that had looked best at our first meeting.
Text Two: Consultation is a beginning, not a decision
An original article by a designer of shared outdoor spaces.
Inviting opinions does not automatically produce a fair design. Confident users may speak first and most often, while people who avoid the existing space can be missing from both meetings and observations. Instead of asking only what people would like to add, find out what prevents them from using the area and what they need to be able to do there.
Consultation should inform a decision, not become a promise that every request will be granted. Space and money are limited, and some preferences will conflict. A group should publish its priorities, such as access, everyday usefulness, manageable upkeep and support for wildlife. It should then explain why particular suggestions have been accepted, altered or rejected.
Temporary layouts can reveal problems that are invisible on a plan, but one busy lunchtime is not a complete test. Weather, season and the time of day may change how a space is used. Existing users may also arrange movable objects in ways that suit them while unintentionally creating obstacles for others. Trials should therefore be combined with access checks, comments from different groups and informed advice about planting and maintenance.
Appearance matters, although neatness should not be confused with quality. If every stem is removed and every surface is hard, a place may lose ecological value and variety. On the other hand, calling an area ‘wildlife-friendly’ should not excuse a lack of care. Clear paths, defined edges and brief explanations can show that a less formal area has been planned rather than forgotten.
Do not judge a shared space by an opening-day photograph. Review it across the year. Notice who returns, who is still excluded, whether routes remain usable, how demanding the upkeep becomes and whether planted areas provide the intended benefits. A successful design is not the one that attracts the fewest criticisms; it is one whose choices can be explained and improved when the evidence changes.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write the speech you would give at the first meeting of a student group redesigning a neglected school courtyard. Explain how the group should make decisions when people want different things from the same space, and how it can tell whether the redesign has succeeded.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.