Making room at break time
Text One: The path through the game
An original account by a student considering how the school courtyard is used.
When I joined the school, I assumed the paved courtyard belonged to everyone. At lunchtime, however, its widest section became a football pitch. The same section was also the shortest route between the dining hall and the science block. Most days, people carrying lunch crossed between the players because walking around the buildings took longer.
One afternoon, a ball struck a younger pupil's tray. Some students immediately demanded an end to football in the courtyard. That sounded simple until one of the players explained that the grass field was often muddy and too far away for a short break. Removing the game would solve one problem by removing an activity which many students valued.
The school council spent several lunchtimes observing the courtyard. We noticed more than arguments about football. Bags were sometimes left across the step-free route. Students who wanted to talk sat on benches close to the game because there were no seats elsewhere. When it rained, nearly everyone crowded beneath the only covered area, including students trying to continue ball games.
A temporary arrangement was introduced. A clear route across the courtyard had to remain free of games and bags. Two benches were moved to a quieter corner which staff could still see. Football continued in the central area, but with softer balls and goals facing away from the doors. On wet days, the covered section was reserved for people sitting or moving between buildings.
The trial did not please everyone. The football area was smaller, and the quieter corner became busy on sunny days. However, disagreements became more specific. Instead of claiming that another group should leave, students could discuss the position of a bench, the direction of a goal or the time allowed for an activity.
I no longer think fairness means dividing every square metre equally. It means making sure that one use of the courtyard does not prevent everyone else from reaching a building, taking part in an activity or spending their break in a different way.
Text Two: One space, several purposes
An original article by a member of staff responsible for shared school spaces.
Outdoor areas should not be organised only in response to the loudest complaint. Before changing a space, observe who uses it, who passes through it and who remains at its edges. Repeat this in different weather and at different times. A courtyard that appears empty before lessons may be under considerable pressure at lunchtime.
Some requirements are not negotiable. Step-free routes, doorways and emergency exits must remain unobstructed, and staff need adequate sightlines for supervision. Other choices can be adjusted. Seating may be moved, equipment may be limited to particular areas, or activities may take place at agreed times rather than occupying the same space throughout every break.
Permanent divisions can create new difficulties. A quiet zone may become isolated or too small, while a large games area may exclude students who do not play. Flexible arrangements are often more useful: movable seating, temporary markings and different wet-weather rules allow the school to respond when patterns of use change.
Students should help identify needs and consider the consequences of proposals. Those requesting a games area should explain how people will cross it safely. Those asking for quieter seating should consider visibility and supervision. Staff must still make decisions about safety, access and what can be managed consistently.
Test a proposal before making it permanent. Useful evidence might include the number and range of students using each area, whether routes remain clear and whether collisions or disputes are reduced. Ask people who have stopped using the space as well as those already present. A fall in complaints is not sufficient evidence if one group has simply decided to stay away.
The best arrangement will not eliminate every disagreement. It will make expectations understandable, protect essential access and allow different activities to take place without one group routinely displacing another. Review the arrangement openly and change it when the evidence shows an unintended result.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a speech for a meeting of the school council, attended by students and staff, in which you propose a fair plan for organising the school's outdoor areas during break and lunchtime.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.