A shared garden that keeps growing
Text One: The planter with three owners
An original account by a student helping to establish a fictional school garden.
Our first gardening meeting attracted twenty-four students, six packets of seeds and more enthusiasm than the courtyard could hold. By the end of the afternoon, every planter contained something. Nobody had decided whether we were trying to grow food, brighten the courtyard or create a place for students to study plants. We called it the garden and assumed the details would arrange themselves.
For the first week, people visited constantly. Several students watered the same planter on Monday because each believed nobody else had done it. By Thursday, another planter had been forgotten. Our paper labels faded after rain, so we could no longer match some plants to their packets or instructions.
One planter was different. Three students had agreed to look after its herbs. They wrote their names and tasks in a notebook kept inside the library, recording when they had watered the plants and what they noticed. If one person was absent, another took over. Their planter was not the largest, but it was the only one whose history we could follow.
The greatest problem arrived during the holidays. We had planned what to plant but not who would have access to the courtyard when the school was closed. A member of staff helped us at short notice, although this had never been agreed as part of her work. When we returned, some plants had survived and others had not.
We restarted with fewer planters. We checked the instructions on the remaining seed packets, replaced the paper labels and created a rota which included weekends and holidays. We also wrote down whom to contact if a task could not be completed.
The new garden looked less ambitious than our first attempt. However, people knew its purpose: to grow a small selection of useful plants and give students experience of caring for them together. There were empty spaces, but they no longer felt like failures waiting to be filled.
Text Two: Growing a project as well as plants
An original article by the coordinator of a shared community garden.
A shared garden needs an agreed purpose. People may want food, flowers, a place to observe living things or simply a pleasant space. These aims can be combined, but not every idea will suit the available site, time and support. Beginning on a manageable scale gives the group a better chance of maintaining what it creates.
Obtain permission to use the space and find out who can enter it at different times. Check where water and tools will come from, how they will be stored and what will happen when the usual volunteers are unavailable. Do not assume that another person will quietly complete neglected work.
Choose plants using reliable instructions and advice appropriate to the location. Appearance alone is not a sufficient guide. Keep the original information, label what has been planted and record significant changes. A brief note can prevent repeated work and help the group understand why one approach succeeded while another did not.
A rota should create responsibility without making the project depend entirely on one individual. Name the task, the time when it should be completed and a backup person. Make it easy for someone to report a problem instead of concealing it or pretending that the task has been done.
Agree how shared resources will be used. Tools should be returned to their proper place, and the group should decide in advance what will happen to anything the garden produces. Visitors also need clear guidance about what they may pick, move or use. Interest in the garden does not automatically give someone permission to change it.
Review the project honestly. A dead plant is not proof that the whole garden has failed, just as one successful planter does not prove that every decision was correct. Compare what happened with the group’s purpose, keep useful records and adjust the next plan. Photographs can show progress, but obtain permission before publishing images that identify people.
A shared garden is sustained by repeated, sometimes ordinary actions. Its future depends less on the excitement of the first planting day than on whether people understand what they have agreed to do afterwards.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write an article for a youth magazine with the title “A shared garden that keeps growing”. Advise readers who want to start or improve a garden managed by a group.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.