A map people can trust
Text One: Thirty-two places to stop
An original account by a student helping to map benches in a fictional town.
Our first map showed thirty-two benches. We had walked the main routes, placed a symbol at each seat and announced that the town now had a guide to places where people could rest. It looked complete because every symbol was the same size and colour.
A resident asked whether the bench behind the courtyard gate was available on Sundays. We did not know. Another wanted to know whether a seat had a back, while a third said that the path to one location was difficult for her to use. We had counted objects and called the result an answer to questions we had not asked.
I felt defensive. We had given several afternoons to the project, and the symbols were not invented. But accuracy about location was only one kind of accuracy. A bench can exist precisely where the map says it does and still fail to offer the rest a particular visitor needs.
We changed the form used by volunteers. It included the date of the visit, observed features and a place to record uncertainty. We checked some locations again with people who might use the map. Their comments did not establish that every route was suitable for everyone; they helped reveal what we had omitted and what we should not claim.
The revised map looked less impressive in one way. Some entries said that opening times had not been confirmed. A few symbols were removed while a detail was checked. I worried that this made us look unreliable, until someone said she would rather know the limit than discover it at a locked gate.
Keeping the map useful now means maintaining it. A new photograph does not guarantee that the situation will remain unchanged, and a comment from a passer-by needs checking before it replaces an entry. The project has become less like finishing a picture of the town and more like looking after a promise about what the picture can tell you.
Text Two: What a symbol promises
An original article by a coordinator of a community mapping project.
A map selects information. Its neat symbols can conceal the decisions behind that selection, especially when readers assume that each entry has been checked in the same way. Before collecting observations, define what the map is intended to help someone decide and what it cannot establish.
Consult intended users while that definition can still change. People may need information about opening arrangements, features or the approach to a location, not only its position. No short form can describe every individual's experience. Avoid converting one person's successful visit into a guarantee for all readers.
Use a consistent recording method and retain dates. Separate direct observation from a report which still needs checking. A blank field should not silently become an affirmative answer when the information is displayed. Volunteers need a shared way to flag uncertainty, and readers need to understand what that flag means.
Photographs may help show a feature but require care. Follow the project's agreed arrangements and avoid unnecessarily including people or private details. An image also has a viewpoint and a date; it is evidence about a visit, not a promise that nothing will change.
Plan for maintenance before celebrating completion. Identify who can review corrections, how changes will be checked and what happens when the group no longer has the resources to update the work. A dated or withdrawn entry may be more honest than an apparently current claim which nobody is responsible for maintaining.
Community effort deserves recognition, but effort cannot substitute for a useful description of the evidence. Criticism from a user can improve a project without cancelling the value of the work already done. The map should earn trust by making both its information and its limits visible.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a contribution to a youth community-project website with the title “A map people can trust”. Advise groups producing a map intended to help people use local facilities.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.