Watching the weather together
Text One: Two sides of the courtyard
An original account by a member of a fictional school weather club.
Our weather club began by recording a temperature beside the classroom window each lunchtime. The chart rose and fell in a satisfyingly clear line. Then somebody moved the thermometer to the shaded side of the courtyard, and the next reading appeared to announce a sudden change in the weather.
We had changed the place as well as the day. I knew this, but I still wanted to keep the dramatic dip because it made our display more interesting. Writing a note beside it felt like admitting that the project was less impressive than the line suggested.
We tried taking readings in both places for a week. The difference was not identical each day. Doors opened, people stood nearby and once the usual reader arrived late. Our notebook acquired more explanations than our original chart had room to display. Some members thought these qualifications made the whole exercise pointless. Others wanted to compare our figures with a published record without first asking how that record had been collected.
I began noticing things which the clean line had hidden. We were more consistent about time on days when the same person remembered. A gap in the chart sometimes meant a missed reading rather than an uneventful day. The place we called shade was not shaded in quite the same way throughout the year.
At the open afternoon, a visitor asked whether our figures proved the courtyard was getting warmer. I said they showed what we had recorded in particular places at particular times. We could explain some differences and had questions about others. That answer sounded smaller than the claim I had once hoped to make, but it led to a much better conversation.
We kept the dip on the chart with its note. The change of location had become part of the project rather than a mistake we needed to disguise. I now find the notebook as interesting as the display, because it tells us what the numbers can reasonably be asked to say.
Text Two: A record people can interpret
An original contribution by a teacher advising the fictional school weather club.
A school observation project can teach careful attention without producing a record suitable for every scientific conclusion. Decide what the group wants to observe and choose a manageable method. Consistency about location, time and equipment helps people interpret differences, but consistency should be described rather than merely assumed.
Keep a record of changes and interruptions. A moved instrument, a late observation or a missed session may matter to the meaning of a chart. A blank should not silently become a zero or an average invented to make the line complete. If an error can be identified, preserve an explanation of the correction instead of quietly replacing the inconvenient entry.
Comparisons require care. Before setting a school chart beside another record, ask whether the measurements, locations and periods are comparable. A short local series cannot settle every question about a wider pattern. Nor does a limitation make every observation useless. Students can examine how conditions and methods affect what they record and learn to make claims whose scale matches the evidence.
Share the work so that the record does not depend on one enthusiastic person being present. Agree what a substitute should do and where notes belong. A beautifully designed chart is difficult to sustain if the routine behind it is unclear or takes more time than members can give.
When presenting results, distinguish the observations, possible explanations and unanswered questions. Notes need to be understandable to a visitor who did not attend the club meetings. An honest qualification can make a display more useful, particularly when it prevents an apparent certainty from travelling further than the evidence supports.
Success need not mean a striking discovery. It can mean that the group understands its own record well enough to explain both what it suggests and what it does not establish. That is a worthwhile result of practical observation, even when the most interesting part of the project is learning why a simple line needs an accompanying notebook.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a contribution to a school website advising students who want to start an observation project like the weather club described in the texts. Explain how they can make the work useful and present its results responsibly.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.