Judging more than agreement
Text One: The speech I wanted to win
An original account by a student judging a fictional school debate.
I agreed with the first speaker before she began. When she described the problem, I nodded so quickly that I nearly missed the reason she gave for her proposed solution. I was listening for recognition of my own position and treating it as evidence that her argument must be strong.
The opposing speaker sounded less confident. He paused over a note and did not produce a phrase which the audience could repeat afterwards. But he identified a consequence the first proposal had not addressed and explained why one of its examples did not settle that consequence. I disliked the direction of his conclusion while finding it harder to dismiss his reasoning.
Our judging group compared notes. Someone had written excellent beside the loudest applause. Another had recorded a precise response to a challenge. Both observations described something that happened in the room, but they were not interchangeable measures of how well the case had been developed.
We returned to the criteria agreed before the event. Presentation mattered because an argument had to reach its audience; it did not allow us to replace reasons with the room's enthusiasm. We also recognised that fluency was not the only way a speaker could make an idea understandable. A pause followed by a clear explanation could be more useful than an uninterrupted run of familiar claims.
I did not reverse every judgement. The first speaker had communicated a genuine concern effectively, and agreement with her did not make her arguments automatically weak. What I changed was the reason attached to the result. I had to distinguish what I supported from what I could justify rewarding in this particular debate.
The final decision still invited disagreement among us. We could explain it through the cases and responses rather than through who sounded most like us. That made the discussion less comfortable in one way and much more worth having.
Text Two: A fair hearing needs an account of the reasons
An original article by a teacher organising the fictional school debate.
Judging a debate is not the same as deciding whether the topic's proposal should be adopted. A judge may hold a strong view while still examining how speakers construct, support and respond to a case. Pretending to have no preferences is less useful than recognising where they could influence attention.
Agree the event's criteria beforehand and explain them to speakers and judges. Content, organisation and communication may all matter within the chosen format. Do not invent new expectations after hearing a speech simply because they reward the person you preferred. Equally, a printed set of headings does not apply itself; judges need to connect their decisions with what a speaker actually did.
Look at reasons, examples and responses to challenges. An example can make a concern vivid without establishing every step from that concern to a proposed solution. A confident assertion may remain unsupported, while a hesitant speaker may nevertheless identify an important weakness. These distinctions require listening, not a general rule that confidence is either proof or deception.
Communication deserves attention too. An audience must be able to follow the case. Passion or a memorable phrase can serve that purpose, and should not be dismissed merely because they affect listeners. The question is how those choices work with the reasoning rather than whether applause can substitute for it.
Keep notes which identify specific moments and their relevance to the agreed criteria. In discussion, allow another judge's observation to test your first impression. A fair process cannot guarantee unanimous results; it can require an explanation which goes beyond personal agreement or a feeling that somebody looked like a winner.
The aim is not to punish conviction or reward uncertainty for its own sake. It is to give each speaker a serious hearing and make the basis of the decision clear enough to examine.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a speech to students who will judge the school debate described in the texts. Recommend how they can reach and explain a fair decision.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.