A fair taste of the trial
Text One: The spoonful at the counter
An original account by a student at a fictional school canteen food trial.
I voted against the new dish before tasting it. Its name contained an ingredient I thought I disliked, and the photograph on the announcement looked nothing like my usual lunch. At the counter, a member of staff offered a small sample and told me where the ingredient information was displayed. I tried it, liked it and immediately wanted to describe myself as an adventurous eater.
My friend did not try it. I began a speech about giving things a chance before she pointed to an ingredient she needed to avoid. I had taken one pleasant surprise and turned it into a judgement about somebody else's decision.
The trial lasted three days. On the first, we received samples while waiting for our normal meals. On the second, the queue was longer and several people went elsewhere rather than wait. The feedback sheet asked whether we liked the new lunch, but did not ask whether we had tasted it or been able to buy it. A blank answer could hide several different experiences.
By the third day, the dish was served from a different counter with a clearer description. Some students still preferred the familiar option. Others said they liked the sample but would not choose a full portion at the advertised price. I had imagined that discovering a good taste would settle the decision; lunch also involved time, money and what else was available.
Our student group suggested making the trial permanent because most of the forms returned were positive. Then we counted how many forms had come back and noticed that friends of the trial organisers had completed many of them. That did not make their answers false. It made our claim about the whole school much larger than our evidence.
I would like the dish to return. I would also like the next trial to ask better questions, so that liking it is one useful answer rather than the only experience the school has invited us to explain.
Text Two: A menu trial is more than a taste test
An original contribution by the catering manager of the fictional school canteen.
A new menu item must work for the people choosing it and the team preparing and serving it. A trial can reveal more than whether a small group enjoys a flavour, provided its questions and arrangements reflect that wider purpose.
Give clear ingredient and dietary information through the school's established process. A sample should be an invitation, not pressure to taste or explain a private reason for declining. People may make different choices for different reasons, and a student's enthusiasm cannot determine what is suitable for somebody else.
Describe the dish in language people can understand and keep relevant information available where the choice is made. Presentation may encourage curiosity, but it should not conceal what is being offered. Keep a workable alternative during the trial so that participation remains a choice.
Observe the practical experience. Can students reach the counter within the time available? Does preparation fit the kitchen's capacity? Do the portion and price make sense as a lunch rather than only as a free spoonful? A favourable response to a sample does not answer every question about providing a regular meal.
Feedback should distinguish trying, buying, declining and being unable to obtain the dish. Ask for reasons without demanding personal disclosures. Note how responses were collected and who may have been missed. A large proportion of positive returned forms is not automatically the same thing as support from a large proportion of all students.
Share the conclusion with its limits. Explain what was learnt, what will change and which questions remain. A trial may support another attempt with different arrangements rather than a simple permanent yes or no. The aim is a menu which can be served reliably and chosen with useful information, not a competition to prove that one group has better taste.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a letter to the catering manager recommending how the next menu trial at the school described in the texts should be organised and evaluated.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.