Piecing the vessel together
Text One: Let the bowl stand again
An original personal account by a ceramics conservator.
The bowl arrived in seventeen pieces, each wrapped separately and placed in a shallow tray. Three fitted together immediately. The others seemed to have agreed upon a shape and then forgotten it. I spent the first morning moving them across the table without joining anything.
Some colleagues thought the fragments should remain flat. Too much of the bowl was missing, they argued, and any support I added would occupy space once filled by clay. I understood the objection. Even so, the surviving pieces included enough of the base and rim to establish the vessel’s height. Leaving them scattered would conceal that relationship as surely as a careless repair might distort it.
I joined the pieces with an adhesive that could be removed and supported the missing sections with a plain cream-coloured material. I did not paint it to resemble the original surface. The difference between the ancient clay and my work needed to be visible, but visibility did not require the bowl to remain collapsed.
Once it stood upright, we noticed something the tray had hidden. The bowl was unusually shallow for its width, and its weight rested towards one side. Those features changed our discussion of how it might have been carried. Reconstruction had not merely produced a more complete-looking object; it had created a new way of examining the surviving evidence.
The finished bowl is not complete, despite its outline. Its pale sections announce every loss, and the joins can be taken apart if later evidence challenges our decisions. I do not regard the repair as the last word on the vessel. I regard it as a careful proposal, strong enough to stand and honest enough to be questioned.
Text Two: Leave the curve unfinished
An original article by an archaeological illustrator preparing material for an excavation briefing.
At the end of the excavation, I was asked to draw a group of pottery fragments for our report. One suggestion was that the larger pieces should first be joined around a supporting frame. A reconstructed vessel would give the team a clear image to present at the final briefing. Clarity, however, was exactly what concerned me.
The fragments included part of a rim and two sections from lower down a vessel. They established the width of the opening, but the middle was absent. On paper, I could extend the surviving curves into a tall jar, a rounded cooking pot or a much shallower container. Each outline fitted the pieces we possessed. None was confirmed by them.
A physical reconstruction would give one possibility the authority of an object. Once a tall jar stood on the table, speakers would call it ‘the jar’, measurements would be taken from its invented height and later readers might not notice where evidence ended. The frame could be labelled as modern, but its single silhouette would still influence every discussion around it.
Instead, I drew each fragment separately and placed three possible profiles beside them. At the briefing, the alternatives were projected together. This was less dramatic than unveiling a completed pot, but it allowed the audience to see why the team had not chosen between the shapes. Questions concentrated on the missing middle rather than on the attractiveness of one reconstruction.
The fragments remained unjoined when they were packed for further study. That was not a failure to reach a result. In this case, the range of possible forms was the result. By leaving the curve unfinished, we preserved evidence that a persuasive reconstruction might have made difficult to see.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about reconstructing damaged pottery.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
102 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.