The day behind the locked gate
Text One: Monday is quieter, not unnecessary
An original letter by a household recycling centre supervisor.
At five minutes to nine on Monday morning, there is usually a short line outside our gate: a car carrying branches from a weekend’s gardening, a tenant with bags from a cleared cupboard and somebody returning a borrowed van before lunchtime. The council’s proposal is to close the centre every Monday because it is our least busy day. Least busy, however, does not mean unused.
I understand that opening the site costs money. Staff must be present, equipment must be operated safely and no public service has an unlimited budget. Yet a total number of weekly visits does not show why people choose a particular day. Some work at weekends. Others can borrow a suitable vehicle only after a relative has finished using it.
Closing on Monday would not make every visit disappear. Some would move to Tuesday, when vehicles already wait at the entrance after work. Other residents would have to keep bulky items at home until they could arrange another journey. The council may save the cost of one opening day, but it should also consider where the inconvenience and additional demand would go.
I am not arguing that every day must have identical hours. I am asking the council to retain a shorter Monday session, from nine until one, and to test it before closing the gate for the whole day. Publish the hourly figures, examine whether visits are being transferred to busier periods and then decide whether the change works.
A locked gate produces a simple entry on a timetable. Its effects are less simple. The value of Monday opening should be judged not only by how many people arrive, but by what alternatives those people actually have.
Text Two: One closed day might still make sense
An original column by a resident who uses the recycling centre.
I used to visit on Saturday and complain about the queue as though it had appeared without explanation. Then I helped my father clear his shed and discovered Monday morning: fewer vehicles, patient staff and enough time to unload without feeling that we were delaying everybody behind us. I can understand why regular Monday users oppose the proposal to close the centre for the whole day.
However, a useful visit does not prove that the present timetable is the best possible one. The council must staff the site whenever it is open, and concentrating those staff on busier days could improve the service for more residents. It would be unreasonable to demand seven unchanged days merely because each day suits somebody.
The supervisor is right, though, that a weekly total cannot answer every question. A person who has borrowed a van for Monday does not necessarily have the same choices as someone who can visit at any time. Nor should the council assume that Monday’s vehicles will vanish rather than joining longer queues on another day.
I could support an all-day Monday closure if the council showed that the remaining opening times could manage the transferred visits and that people with limited options had been considered. Before that, a four-hour Monday trial seems a sensible test. It would reduce costs while revealing whether a smaller service could meet the need the supervisor describes.
The argument should not become a contest between people who value convenience and officials who value savings. Both matter. The fairest decision will follow the journeys displaced by the locked gate, not simply admire the blank space it creates on the timetable.
Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about how the proposed Monday closure should be judged.
Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.
102 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.