Skip to content

Course home

Question bank·2.3.7 AO3 in Section A
Sign up

2.3.7 AO3 in Section A

MediumHard
1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829303132333435363738394041424344454647484950515253545556575859606162636465666768697071727374757677787980
Question 14

Changing the record

Text One: Bronze is not proof

An original letter from an archive researcher to a local newspaper.

Beside the harbour, a bronze panel tells visitors that the seawall was ‘designed by Borough Engineer Edwin Marsh and completed in 1908’. The sentence is brief, polished and wrong.

The evidence is not hidden in a private collection. A calculation book in the town archive is signed by Mina Hart, an assistant engineer in Marsh’s department. The council minutes approve ‘Miss Hart’s revised sea-defence plan’, while the surviving contracts show that Marsh managed the department which carried it out. These records do not remove Marsh from the history, but they do remove his claim to have designed the wall.

Thousands of people pass the panel each summer. Few will visit the archive afterwards to test what they have read. Bronze has a grammar of certainty: it appears to say not only that this happened, but that no further question is necessary. That authority makes accuracy more important, not less.

The council has replied that the panel can be reconsidered when the harbour signs are next renewed. This treats delay as though it were neutral. It is not. Every day the existing words remain in place, the town repeats the same account to another group of visitors. A maintenance schedule should not decide how long an unsupported claim continues to be taught.

Nor should the correction simply exchange one figure on a pedestal for another. Hart produced the revised design; Marsh led the department; named contractors and hundreds of labourers turned drawings into stone. A truthful panel would distinguish those contributions instead of compressing the whole seawall into one celebrated man.

A temporary plate could be installed now, with references directing interested readers to the records. The permanent wording can follow after consultation. Correcting the panel would not weaken confidence in the town’s history. It would show that the town values evidence more highly than the convenience of leaving metal untouched.

Text Two: Writing labels in pencil

An original article by a museum curator.

Museum labels are printed in ink, but they ought to be imagined in pencil. Their purpose is to communicate the best account supported by the evidence available at the time, not to announce that research has ended.

For many years, the label on one of our mechanical looms stated that it was ‘invented by Jonas Vale in 1884’. Then a family donated a workshop notebook containing earlier diagrams initialled R.W. and C.W. A letter written by Vale also praised Ruth and Clara Wynn for improving the loom’s feeding mechanism. The old sentence could no longer stand unchanged.

The notebook did not, however, provide a complete replacement. Several pages were missing, and the surviving diagrams concerned one mechanism rather than the whole machine. It would have been careless to remove Vale’s name immediately and award the entire invention to the Wynn sisters. New evidence had made the old certainty impossible without creating a new certainty of its own.

We placed a card beside the loom explaining that its attribution was under review. Over the following months, we compared the notebook with patent records, workshop accounts and correspondence held elsewhere. The revised label now says that the loom was developed in Vale’s workshop and that its feeding mechanism drew on designs recorded by Ruth and Clara Wynn.

Some visitors asked why we had not made that change on the day the notebook arrived. Others wanted the Wynn sisters to replace Vale as the single answer. Both responses sought a clean transfer of credit, whereas the documents pointed towards collaboration and left some questions open.

We dated the new label and made a summary of the evidence available beside it. A museum should not conceal the route by which its account has changed. Revising a display is not an admission that knowledge is worthless; it is evidence that knowledge remains answerable to what can be discovered.

Compare how the writers present their ideas and perspectives about correcting public accounts of the past.

Support your answer with detailed references to both texts, including brief quotations.

[15]
Markscheme

2.3.7 AO3 in Section A Questions

  1. IGCSE
  2. /English Language
  3. /2.3.7 AO3 in Section A

102 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.3.7 AO3 in Section A. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.

More questions