Wish fulfilment
Wish fulfilment
Wish fulfilment is Freud's idea that a dream lets an unconscious desire be acted out in disguised form, giving it an outlet that waking life denies.
- Freud argued that the purpose of every dream is wish fulfilment.
- A dream lets an unconscious desire that waking life blocks be acted out safely inside your head.
- Those wishes sit in the unconscious mind, held down there by repression, so you never know you have them.
- The wish starts in the id, and because the ego is weakened in sleep the wish pushes up and the dream shows it being met.
- Dream work recasts that wish as symbols and a storyline, so the manifest content you remember stands in for the latent content underneath it.
- Because the wish arrives in disguise, the sleeper watches the dream through to the end without waking.
Where the wish comes from
Id
The id is the part of the personality present from birth that seeks the immediate satisfaction of basic desires, working on impulse rather than reason.
- The id is the part of your personality that wants satisfaction now and will not wait, like a small child demanding a treat.
- In sleep the ego is weakened, so the id's wish pushes up towards consciousness.
- The dream then shows the wish being met, though almost always behind a disguise.
- If you have begged for a puppy for months and been refused, you may dream of a dog bounding round the garden with you, so the id gets its turn while you sleep.
- A frightening dream looks like a problem for wish fulfilment, and Freud's answer was that the disguise had partly failed and let the anxiety through.
- Freud allowed that a dream borrows its material from the day just gone, so the same buried wish can be dressed in whatever the dreamer happened to see that evening.
Manifest and latent content
Manifest content
The manifest content is the storyline of a dream as the dreamer remembers it: the images, people and events that actually play out on the surface.
- Manifest content is the surface story of the dream, the part you could describe to a friend the next morning.
- Latent content is the hidden, symbolic meaning behind that story, which is the repressed wish the dream really expresses.
- The manifest content of one dream is leaving your bag on the train and watching the doors close.
- The latent content is an underlying fear of losing something or someone that matters to you.
- The lost bag is a stand-in, so the fear reaches you without ever naming what you are really afraid of.
Dream work
Latent content
The latent content is the hidden meaning behind a dream: the repressed unconscious wishes and feelings that the dream really expresses.
- An undisguised wish would shock you awake, so the ego disguises it first through a process Freud called dream work.
- Dream work turns the hidden wish into symbols and a storyline you can watch without alarm.
- Reaching the latent content means reading those symbols backwards, which is what dream analysis does.
- Manifest content is the dream as remembered, and latent content is what that dream means.
- The manifest story is not the message, because the message is always the latent content.
- The wish is not shown openly, since in almost every dream it is disguised.
Freud's case study of the Wolfman
- Freud's fullest worked example is Freud (1918), his dream analysis of a patient he called the Wolfman, a Russian man in his twenties.
- He came to Freud with depression after his sister and his father had both taken their own lives.
- Treatment centred on a childhood dream in which his bedroom window swung open by itself and six or seven white wolves sat watching him from the tree outside.
- Freud read the wolves, the manifest content, as a disguise for the latent content, a repressed fear of his father.
- Their whiteness stood for his parents' bedclothes, and the tree for a Christmas tree, because the dream had happened at Christmas.
- The wolves had also taken the place of the presents he had been promised, so the dream turned an expected treat into something frightening.
- Four years of interviews produced rich, detailed data about one mind.
- Freudian dream analysis is still used in some talking therapies, for instance treating a bereaved person's recurring dreams as a route to buried grief.
- The wolves carried the meaning Freud gave them because of this patient's own life, so the same image in someone else's dream would not stand for the same thing.
- The symbols cannot be looked up in a fixed list, because Freud reached each one through what this patient told him about his childhood.
- The pseudonym is used because Freud kept his patients' names out of print.
The problem of subjectivity
- The main criticism of Freud's theory is how much rests on the interpreter's own judgement, which is the problem of subjectivity.
- There is nothing to measure, so two therapists can give the same dream two different meanings and nothing decides which of them is right.
- Freud may have read dreams in whichever way suited his own theory, which opens every interpretation to bias.
- Freud never set out in advance what a dream would have to contain for his account to be wrong, so no dream a patient reported could ever count against it.
- The Wolfman was also one man in therapy for mental health problems, so his dreams may not be typical of other people's.
- The account leaned on him recalling a childhood dream accurately years afterwards, and most dreams fade within minutes of waking.
Turning this into marks
- When manifest and latent content are both asked for, make them genuinely separate rather than describing the storyline twice.
- Name subjectivity as the problem, because writing that the theory is hard to prove does not secure the knowledge mark.
- The mark most often lost is retelling the Wolfman's dream without saying what Freud took the wolves to stand for.
- What is wish fulfilment?
- Which part of the personality produces the wishes that dreams satisfy?
- What is the difference between manifest and latent content?
- In Freud (1918), what did the white wolves stand for?
- Why does subjectivity make the theory hard to test?