Four terms that do different jobs
- Obedience and conformity both describe changing what you do because of other people, but the pressure comes from a different place in each.
- Deindividuation and the bystander effect both describe what being among other people does to you, one to your sense of self and one to your willingness to help.
Obedience
- Obedience is following a direct order given by someone you see as an authority figure.
- The order is explicit and it comes from someone you see as being above you, such as a teacher, a police officer, a manager or a parent.
- You do not have to agree with the order, so obeying tells you nothing about what you privately think.
- The tell-tale sign of obedience is that you can name the person who told you what to do.
Conformity
- Conformity is changing your behaviour or opinions to match a group or majority, because of real or imagined pressure from that group.
- Nobody gives you an order, and very often nobody says anything to you at all.
- The pressure can be imagined, because simply believing the group expects something of you is enough to move you.
- The tell-tale sign of conformity is that you cannot name one person who told you to change, only a group you did not want to stand out from.
- Your teacher tells you to put your phone away and you do it, which is obedience because a named authority figure gave you a direct order.
- Nobody asks you to, but everyone else at the table has already put their phone face down, so you do the same, which is conformity because the pressure came from the group.
- The behaviour is identical in both, so it is the source of the pressure that decides which term applies.
Deindividuation
Deindividuation
Losing your sense of individual identity in a crowd, often because you feel anonymous, which can loosen your normal self-control.
- Deindividuation is losing your sense of individual identity when you are part of a crowd or group.
- It is most likely when you feel anonymous, for example in a large crowd, in a uniform, or with your face covered.
- Feeling anonymous loosens your normal self-control, so you may do things you would never do on your own.
- Deindividuation is not the same as conformity, because it describes what happens to your sense of who you are rather than your behaviour coming into line with a group.
The bystander effect
Bystander effect
The finding that a person is less likely to help someone in need when other people are present than when they are alone.
- The bystander effect is the finding that you are less likely to help someone in need when other people are present than when you are alone.
- It is a finding about how many other people are there, not about how kind or unkind you happen to be.
- The usual explanation offered for it is diffusion of responsibility, where each person present assumes someone else will act.
- The effect runs the opposite way to most people's expectations, since more people present means less help rather than more.
- Do not treat obedience and conformity as interchangeable, because obedience needs an authority figure and conformity needs a group.
- Do not describe the bystander effect as a kind of person, because it is a finding about what the presence of others does to helping.
- Do not reduce deindividuation to simply being in a crowd, because the term is about losing your individual identity inside it.
Turning this into marks
- Name the source of the pressure, because obedience needs the words authority figure or direct order and conformity needs group or majority.
- When you are given a scenario, quote the detail that settles it, such as a named person issuing an instruction or an unspoken group standard.
- The mark most often lost is describing the bystander effect as a type of person rather than as the finding that helping falls when others are present.
- What is obedience?
- How does conformity differ from obedience?
- What is deindividuation, and when is it most likely?
- What is the bystander effect?