Asha has had low mood and little energy for several weeks. She interprets a missed invitation as proof that nobody wants her around.
Wiles compared patients receiving CBT plus usual care with patients receiving usual care alone. The percentage of patients who responded after six months is shown below.
| Treatment | Patients who responded |
|---|---|
| CBT plus usual care | 46% |
| Usual care alone | 22% |
Discuss biological and psychological explanations of depression and the use of antidepressant medication and CBT. Calculate the difference between the response rates and use it in your answer. In your discussion, refer to Asha's thinking, how the treatments work and one strength or limitation of each treatment, and reach a reasoned conclusion.
82 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 2.4 Psychological problems, covering 2.4.1 Introduction to mental health, 2.4.2 Changing incidence of mental health problems, 2.4.3 Effects of mental health problems on individuals, 2.4.4 Effects of mental health problems on society, 2.4.5 Characteristics of clinical depression, 2.4.6 Biological explanation of depression, 2.4.7 Psychological explanation of depression, 2.4.8 Therapies for depression, 2.4.9 Wiles' study of CBT, 2.4.10 Characteristics of addiction, 2.4.11 Biological explanation of addiction, 2.4.12 Psychological explanation of addiction, and 2.4.13 Interventions or therapies for addiction. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.