This article covers 3.2.4 Psychological problems of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Recorded Cases Have Risen
- The recorded incidence of mental health problems has risen over the past few decades.
- A rising number of recorded cases does not automatically mean more people are becoming unwell.
- How problems are counted and diagnosed has changed, and that alone can push the figures up.
Key Idea
- A rise in recorded cases can reflect better recording rather than more illness.
- To judge a trend, you always have to ask what has changed about the counting.
Why More Cases Get Counted
- Diagnostic manuals now recognise more conditions than they did in the past, so more experiences fit a named category.
- GPs and other professionals are now more likely to spot and record a mental health problem during an appointment.
- More people come forward for help, so cases that once went unrecorded now appear in the statistics.
Example
- Conditions such as anxiety are far more widely recognised today than they were a generation ago.
- When a condition gains a clear label, more people can be diagnosed with it, which lifts the recorded incidence.
Changing Attitudes Since 1959
- The 1959 Mental Health Act encouraged treating people voluntarily and moving care out of large institutions.
- As the law and public attitudes softened, seeking help came to feel less shameful.
- Because more people now feel able to speak up, more problems are reported and recorded than in earlier decades.
Note
- Compare the 1980s, when mental health was rarely discussed openly, with today, when public campaigns encourage people to talk.
- That growing openness is a similarity that links the periods, even as the recorded numbers differ.
Real Change or Better Recording?
- Part of the rise may be real, if the increased challenges of modern living, such as social isolation and online pressure, genuinely mean more people struggle.
- Part of the rise is almost certainly better recording, driven by broader classification and greater openness.
- The two causes are hard to separate, so you should present any trend as a mix rather than proof of a real epidemic.
Culture Shapes What Counts as a Problem
- Beliefs about mental health vary between cultures, so the same behaviour can be understood very differently around the world.
- Cultures disagree both about what causes a mental health problem and about what should even count as one.
- Because these views differ, the definition of a mental health problem is not fixed or universal.
Key Idea
- What counts as a mental health problem depends partly on the culture doing the judging.
- This insight is the basis of cultural relativism, a key evaluation point in this topic.
Medical, Spiritual and Social Views
- In the UK, mental health problems are usually seen through a medical lens, as conditions with biological and psychological causes.
- In some other cultures, the same experiences may be understood in spiritual terms, or as a sign of something within the wider community.
- Because the believed cause differs, the response differs too, ranging from medication and therapy to religious or community support.
Example
- Hearing voices may be treated as a symptom to assess in one culture, yet understood as a meaningful spiritual experience in another.
- The behaviour is the same, but the label and the care that follow depend on cultural beliefs.
Cultural Relativism
- Cultural relativism says behaviour can only be judged fairly within the culture it belongs to.
- It follows that there is no single, culture-free definition of a mental health problem.
- You can use this as a strong evaluation point whenever a question treats one culture's view as the only correct one.
Note
- A diagnostic system built in one culture may not fit the beliefs and norms of another.
- This is why clinicians are encouraged to take a person's cultural background into account when making a diagnosis.
Why This Matters for Diagnosis
- If a test ignores culture, it may wrongly label a normal cultural practice as a problem.
- It may also miss real distress that is expressed in a way the test was not designed to spot.
- Taking culture into account therefore makes diagnosis fairer and more accurate for everyone.
Stigma Is Falling, Recognition Is Rising
Definition
Stigma
Stigma is the unfair negative judgement attached to a characteristic, such as having a mental health problem, which can leave a person feeling ashamed or being treated differently.
- Mental health problems are recognised more clearly today than in the past, so more people can name what they are experiencing.
- The stigma once attached to mental health has lessened, so people feel less judged for speaking up.
- Because more people come forward and seek help, this shift changes how many cases are recorded.
Key Idea
- Better recognition and less stigma mean more people seek help and receive a diagnosis.
- Recognition is not the same as prevalence, so more diagnoses need not mean more illness.
Growing Openness About Mental Health
- The public understands mental health problems better than it did a few decades ago.
- As understanding grows, there is far less shame in talking openly about how you feel.
- Less shame encourages more people to come forward to a GP or a support service.
Example
- UK campaigns such as Time to Change and Heads Together have encouraged people to talk about mental health without shame.
- Compared with the 1980s, when the subject was rarely discussed, far more people now feel able to seek a diagnosis.
Recognition Versus Prevalence
- Greater recognition can raise the recorded incidence, because cases that were once hidden are now counted.
- Yet the true prevalence, the real number of people affected, may not have changed at all.
- So a rise in recorded cases can reflect openness rather than a genuine increase in problems.
Common Mistake
- Do not confuse recognition, how well problems are noticed, with prevalence, how many people actually have them.
- In an answer, make clear that more recorded cases can simply come from more openness.
Explaining the Change Clearly
- State that recognition has risen and stigma has fallen over recent decades.
- Distinguish recognition from prevalence so the examiner sees you understand the difference.
- Explain the causal chain: less stigma leads to more help-seeking, which lifts the recorded figures.
Self review
- Give two reasons the recorded incidence of mental health problems may have risen.
- What did the 1959 Mental Health Act change about care and attitudes?
- What is cultural relativism, and why does it matter for diagnosis?
- How is recognition different from prevalence?
- How does a fall in stigma affect the number of recorded cases?