This article covers 3.2.3 Brain and neuropsychology of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Penfield's Aim
- Wilder Penfield operated on patients with severe epilepsy and wanted to find the exact spot triggering their seizures before removing it.
- Along the way he set out to map which parts of the cortex produced which experiences.
- He focused on part of the temporal lobe that he called the interpretive cortex.
Key Idea
- Penfield's aim was to link points on the brain's surface to the experiences they produced.
- If one spot reliably produced one experience, that would be evidence for localisation of function.
Method: Stimulating a Conscious Brain
- Patients were kept awake under local anaesthetic, because the brain itself feels no pain.
- Penfield touched points on the exposed cortex with a weak electrical probe and asked each patient to report what they felt.
- He marked every stimulated spot with a small numbered ticket so he could record exactly where each response came from.
Example
- When Penfield stimulated one spot on the temporal lobe, a patient suddenly heard a familiar tune as if it were playing in the room.
- Touching the very same spot again brought back the same tune.
- Other points brought back smells, scenes or the feeling of having been somewhere before.
Findings
- Stimulating the temporal lobe produced vivid, dream-like memories and sensations that felt real to the patient.
- The same point tended to trigger the same experience each time, which suggested that experience was tied to that location.
- This linked particular areas of the interpretive cortex directly to particular memories, supporting localisation of function.
Note
- Penfield did not conclude that the whole brain stores memories, but that the temporal lobe plays a key part in replaying them.
- That fits the wider picture in which different areas take on different jobs.
Evaluation
- Strong support for localisation: because the same spot reliably produced the same experience, the findings tie specific temporal-lobe areas to specific memories.
- Useful in practice: the mapping let surgeons remove the tissue causing seizures while sparing areas that carried important functions, which improved epilepsy operations.
- Unusual sample limits generalisability: every patient had severe epilepsy and an already-abnormal brain, so their responses to stimulation may not match how a typical brain would react.
- Hard to verify: the reports were private experiences only the patient could feel, and artificial stimulation may have created dream-like sensations rather than genuine stored memories, so they cannot be fully checked.
Self review
- What did Penfield stimulate, and how were the patients kept comfortable?
- What did patients report when the temporal lobe was stimulated?
- What does the study show about localisation of function?
- Why does the sample make the findings hard to generalise?