This article covers 3.2.2 Language, thought and communication of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Properties of Human Communication
- Human communication has several properties that animal communication simply does not.
- The standout one is displacement, the power to talk about things that are not here and now.
- Psychologists list a set of features of true language, which gives you a checklist for comparing humans with animals.
Key Idea
- Displacement lets you discuss the past, the future and ideas that are not present at all.
- These features of true language let you judge how far animal signals fall short.
Displacement: Talking Beyond the Present
- Displacement means your words can refer to things far away in time or space, or things that do not exist yet.
- Because of it you can plan ahead, retell yesterday and imagine what has never happened.
- Animal signals are triggered by the present moment, so they cannot point to distant or made-up events.
- This is the clearest single gap between human language and animal communication.
Example
- You can text a mate shall we go to Nando's on Saturday, planning an event days before it happens.
- You can also moan about last night's match long after it finished.
- No animal signal can reach forward to next Saturday or back to last night like that.
Semanticity and Creativity
- Semanticity means your words are symbols that stand for objects and ideas even when they are nowhere in sight.
- Creativity, or productivity, means you can build brand-new sentences that nobody has ever said before.
- Structure dependence means the order of the words changes the meaning, so grammar carries information too.
- These sit alongside displacement in the features that make human communication a true language.
Note
- Human language is like a box of Lego: a fixed set of pieces you recombine into endless new builds.
- Most animal communication is more like a few pre-set buttons that only ever do the same fixed jobs.
Comparing Humans and Animals
- Animal communication is tied to immediate needs and uses a small, fixed set of signals.
- Human language is flexible and open-ended, meeting far more of these features.
- Some animals tick one or two features, such as the direction and distance in a bee's dance, but none tick them all.
- So the fair conclusion is that both groups communicate, but only human communication counts as true language.
Common Mistake
- Do not claim animals have no communication at all; theirs is real but limited.
- Do not just list the differences either; the higher marks come from weighing them into a clear conclusion.
Reaching an Evaluated Conclusion
- Pick two clear human properties, such as displacement and creativity, and show exactly what animals cannot do.
- Use these features of true language as your framework so the comparison is systematic rather than a random list.
- The mark most people drop is the conclusion, so finish by stating that only human communication meets all the criteria for true language.
Self review
- What is displacement in human language?
- What does semanticity mean?
- Name two properties of human language that animal communication lacks.
- Give an evaluated conclusion on how human and animal communication differ.