At an after-school sports club, a headteacher asks one group of 40 pupils to put away their phones. Seventy per cent comply. A sixth-form pupil who has no official role gives the same instruction to a second group of 40 pupils; 16 comply.
Calculate the percentage of pupils who complied with the sixth-form pupil's instruction and the percentage-point difference between the two groups. Then evaluate what these results suggest about legitimate authority as an explanation for the difference in obedience. In your answer, include one reason why the pattern supports this explanation and one reason why the results cannot establish causation.
96 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 2.1 Social influence, covering 2.1.1 Conformity: social and dispositional factors, 2.1.2 Asch's study of conformity, 2.1.3 Obedience: social factors, 2.1.4 Obedience: dispositional factors, 2.1.5 Prosocial and bystander behaviour, 2.1.6 Piliavin's subway study, and 2.1.7 Crowd and collective behaviour. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.