Researchers staged a collapse in the indoor passenger cabin of a ferry during short crossings. The same male actor either appeared ill and carried a walking cane or smelled of alcohol and carried a bottle. Observers counted the passengers who could clearly see the collapse and recorded whether anyone helped.
| Victim condition | Number of passengers | Trials in which help was given | Median time until first help on trials where help was given |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cane | 8–12 | 94% | 10 seconds |
| Cane | 28–32 | 96% | 9 seconds |
| Alcohol | 8–12 | 54% | 34 seconds |
| Alcohol | 28–32 | 58% | 31 seconds |
A psychologist claims, ‘These results support Piliavin's cost-reward model and show a strong bystander effect.’
Using the data and your knowledge of Piliavin's subway study, evaluate the psychologist's claim.
96 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 2.1 Social influence, covering 2.1.1 Conformity: social and dispositional factors, 2.1.2 Asch's study of conformity, 2.1.3 Obedience: social factors, 2.1.4 Obedience: dispositional factors, 2.1.5 Prosocial and bystander behaviour, 2.1.6 Piliavin's subway study, and 2.1.7 Crowd and collective behaviour. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.