A psychologist investigates whether a two-minute planning period affects pupils' accuracy when proofreading a short notice. In one investigation, pupils complete the task in a quiet study room arranged by the psychologist. The same desk, lighting, instructions and time limit are used for everyone, and the psychologist decides whether pupils have the planning period. In a second investigation, pupils complete the task during a normal lesson in their usual classroom. The psychologist still decides whether pupils have the planning period, but other features of the classroom cannot all be kept the same.
Give the type of experiment represented by each investigation.
Compare the two investigations in terms of confidence in cause-and-effect conclusions and ecological validity.
96 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 1.4 Research methods, covering 1.4.1 Formulation of testable hypotheses, 1.4.2 Types of variable, 1.4.3 Sampling methods, 1.4.4 Experimental method and designs, 1.4.5 Types of experiment, 1.4.6 Non-experimental research methods, 1.4.7 Correlation, 1.4.8 Research procedures, 1.4.9 Planning and conducting research, and 1.4.10 Ethical considerations. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.