This article covers 3.1.4 Research methods of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Non-Experimental Methods: Studying Behaviour as It Really Is
- An experiment deliberately changes one variable to see its effect, but a non-experimental method does not manipulate anything.
- Instead, you measure or record behaviour as it naturally happens, or you ask people to report on themselves.
- Because no variable is controlled, these methods cannot show that one thing causes another, only describe or find links.
- In return, they often give you more realistic or more detailed data than a tightly controlled experiment can.
- The four you need are observations, questionnaires, interviews and case studies.
- These methods describe behaviour or find relationships; they do not test cause and effect.
- For each one, learn what it is, how it is done, one clear example, and one strength and one weakness.
Observation Studies: Watching Behaviour Directly
Observation
A method that collects data by watching and recording what participants do, rather than asking them about it.
- In an observation you watch and record what people actually do, rather than asking them about it.
- A naturalistic observation watches behaviour in its normal everyday setting, such as children in a real playground.
- Its strength is high ecological validity, because the behaviour is genuine and not staged.
- Its weakness is a lack of control, because you cannot stop other factors affecting what you see.
- A controlled observation watches behaviour in a set-up situation, such as a room arranged by the researcher.
- This gives more control over other factors, but the setting feels less natural, so behaviour may change.
- In an overt observation people know they are being watched, which is more ethical but can make them act unnaturally.
- In a covert observation people do not know, so their behaviour is more natural, but there are ethical concerns about consent.
- In a participant observation the researcher joins the group, while in a non-participant observation they stay separate and just watch.
Recording with Behavioural Categories
Behavioural categories
Clear, separate and observable actions that a behaviour is broken into so it can be recorded consistently, for example on a tally chart.
- You cannot simply write down everything at once, so first you break the behaviour into clear behavioural categories.
- Each category must be a separate, observable action, such as pushing, so two people would record it the same way.
- You then tally each category every time it happens, which turns what you see into countable data.
Checking Reliability with a Second Observer
Inter-observer reliability
How far two or more observers watching the same behaviour agree on what they record; close agreement means the observation is more reliable.
- To check the recording is not just one person's opinion, two observers watch the same behaviour at the same time.
- They record separately, then compare their tallies to see how closely they agree.
- Close agreement means high inter-observer reliability, which makes the results more trustworthy and objective.
- To study aggression in a school playground, two observers tally set categories such as pushing, name-calling and sharing.
- They watch from the edge without joining in, so this is a naturalistic, non-participant observation.
- Comparing the two tally sheets afterwards checks their inter-observer reliability.
Questionnaires: Asking in Writing
Questionnaire
A self-report method that collects data through a set of written questions, which can be given to many people at once.
- A questionnaire is a set of written questions that a person answers themselves.
- Because it is written, you can give it to a large number of people quickly and cheaply.
- A closed question gives fixed options, such as yes or no or a rating from 1 to 5.
- Closed questions give numerical data that is quick to count and easy to compare or put in a graph.
- An open question lets people answer in their own words, such as explaining why they feel stressed.
- Open questions give richer, more detailed data, but it takes longer to make sense of the answers.
- A strength is that questionnaires reach a large sample, so the findings may represent more people; a weakness is that people may not answer honestly or may misread a question.
- A survey asks 200 students to rate their exam stress from 1 to 5, which is a closed question giving quick numerical data.
- It then adds an open question, 'What worries you most about exams?', to capture the reasons behind the ratings.
Interviews: Asking Face to Face
Interview
A self-report method that collects data by asking people spoken questions, so answers can be followed up.
- An interview collects data by asking spoken questions, usually face to face.
- A structured interview asks the same set questions in the same order every time.
- This makes it easy to repeat and to compare answers between people, but the fixed questions cannot follow up anything interesting.
- An unstructured interview is more like a guided conversation, where the interviewer can follow up whatever the person says.
- This gives richer, more detailed data, but the answers are harder to compare and to analyse.
- Because it is done in person, the interviewer can build rapport, which may help someone open up.
Social Desirability Bias in Self-Report
Social desirability bias
The tendency for people to answer in a way that makes them look good, rather than giving an honest response.
- Both questionnaires and interviews rely on people reporting on themselves, which brings a problem called social desirability bias.
- This is where people answer in a way that makes them look good, rather than giving the honest truth.
- It is stronger in a face-to-face interview, because the person is sitting in front of someone judging their answer.
- It lowers the validity of the data, and you can reduce it by making answers anonymous and questions neutral.
- A questionnaire on how much you exercise may get inflated answers, because people like to seem active.
- The same questions asked anonymously online usually get more honest answers than in a face-to-face interview.
Case Studies: One Case in Depth
Case study
An in-depth investigation of a single person, group or event, usually combining several methods to gather rich, detailed data.
- A case study is an in-depth investigation of a single person, group or event.
- It usually combines several methods, such as interviews, observations and tests, to build a full picture.
- It is often longitudinal, meaning the same case is followed over a long period of time.
- Case studies are especially useful for rare cases that could not be studied any other way, such as unusual brain damage.
Rich Qualitative Data, but Hard to Generalise
Qualitative data
Data in the form of words, such as what someone says in an interview, which gives detail about how people think and feel but is harder to compare.
- Case studies mostly produce qualitative data, meaning rich descriptions in words rather than numbers.
- The strength is this depth of detail, which can reveal things a quick study would miss.
- One weakness is that a single case may be unusual, so you cannot safely generalise the findings to everyone.
- Another weakness is that the close involvement of the researcher can lead to biased interpretation.
- A famous case study might follow one patient with severe memory loss over many years, using tests and interviews.
- It reveals a huge amount about how memory works, but that one unusual brain may not represent anyone else.
Weighing Up the Four Methods
- Observations show what people actually do, which is more honest than what they say, but they cannot tell you why.
- Questionnaires reach large samples and are easy to repeat, but the answers can be shallow or dishonest.
- Interviews trade the large sample of a questionnaire for greater depth and the chance to follow up.
- Case studies give the most depth of all, but the least ability to generalise.
- Do not confuse a naturalistic observation with a case study: an observation records behaviour, a case study investigates one whole individual in depth.
- When you evaluate, match the point to the method: sample size for questionnaires, depth for case studies, ecological validity for observations.
Answering a Methods Question
- Name the method the scenario points to, and say briefly how it would be carried out.
- Justify it by linking it to what the study needs, such as a large sample, honest behaviour or in-depth detail.
- The mark most people drop is giving a generic 'it is unrealistic' evaluation, so instead give one strength and one weakness that genuinely fit that method.
- What is the difference between a naturalistic and a controlled observation?
- Why do researchers use behavioural categories and check inter-observer reliability?
- What is the difference between an open and a closed question?
- What is social desirability bias and why is it worse in interviews?
- Give one strength and one weakness of a case study.